Challenges Of Pre-Existing Conditions In Ontario Car Accident Claims

Our team of lawyers, legal assistants, and administrative professionals are dedicated to providing the best possible services for our clients. We take pride in the opportunity to make a meaningful impact in our clients’ lives.

We know that no one wants to find themselves needing a lawyer – whether you’ve lost your job, are separating from your spouse, or were injured in an accident.

During these vulnerable moments in life, you need not only an experienced professional in your corner, but someone who listens, understands what you’re going through, and can take on some of the emotional burden. That’s what our team provides.

While our profession is the law, our mission is peace of mind.

Explore Firm Details

Insurance companies often scrutinize these cases, trying to attribute injuries to prior health issues instead of the accident. Let's discuss how pre-existing conditions affect the compensation process and strategies...

Canada Ontario Litigation, Mediation & Arbitration

Navigating an Ontario car accident claim becomes more complex when pre-existing conditions are involved.

What Are Pre-Existing Conditions?

Pre-existing conditions are medical issues that existed before the car accident, such as back problems, joint disorders, or previous concussions. These conditions can complicate the assessment of injuries caused by a car accident.

Impact on Ontario Car Accident Claims

Causation Challenges: Proving that the injuries are directly related to the accident is crucial. In some cases, the proof required is that the accident significantly worsened a pre-existing condition.
Insurance Company Skepticism: Insurers may argue that the damages claimed are due to pre-existing conditions to reduce their liability.
Compensation Reduction: If insurers can show that injuries are related to pre-existing conditions, compensation may be reduced.

Proving the Impact of the Accident

To overcome these challenges, it's crucial to establish a clear link between the accident and the injuries:

Medical Documentation: Keep comprehensive medical records that distinguish between pre- and post-accident conditions.
Expert Medical Testimony: Experts can provide credible testimony on how the accident aggravated pre-existing conditions or caused new injuries.
Consistent Medical Treatment: Continuity in medical treatment strengthens your claim by showing how the accident impacted your health.

Legal Strategies for Handling Pre-Existing Conditions in Ontario

Full Disclosure: Be upfront about pre-existing conditions to avoid undermining your credibility.
The "Thin Skull" Doctrine: In Ontario, this legal principle holds that a defendant is responsible for all injuries, even if the plaintiff was more vulnerable due to pre-existing conditions.
Accurate Medical Assessment: Ensure that medical assessments clearly separate injuries caused by the accident from pre-existing issues.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.