ARTICLE
5 February 2025

NCAI Formed A Tribal Citizenship Protection Task Force To Prepare For This Moment. But Then Killed It

GB
Galanda Broadman

Contributor

Galanda Broadman PLLC tackles critical and complex litigation, bet-the-company business matters and regulatory disputes for tribal governments, enterprises and citizens. We offer big-firm sophistication, with agility and efficiency. We understand what’s at stake for Indigenous America. When it’s critical, we create solutions and achieve results.

According to its proposed "Charge," the Task Force was to "[e]valuate and monitor external political and legal threats to Tribal citizenship" and "undertake...work as necessary to help NCAI defend against emerging threats to Tribal citizenship."
United States Government, Public Sector

In November 2020, NCAI formed the Tribal Citizenship Policy and Protection Task Force, by Resolution.

Accordingto its proposed "Charge," the Task Force was to "[e]valuate and monitor external political and legal threats to Tribal citizenship" and "undertake...work as necessary to help NCAI defend against emerging threats to Tribal citizenship."

Two such threats were the first Trump administration's"treatment of Native Nations as racial groups under Medicaid rules and disregard of Tribal citizenship data as a basis for federal COVID-relief funding."

But within months, the NCAI Executive Board ignored both the Resolution and proposed Charge, essentially killing the Task Force.That is because any effort that remotely touches Indigenous or Tribal human rights, most notably the right to belong, is anathema to NCAI politicians.

Now theTrump administration questions whether Tribal citizens enjoy American birthright citizenship and ICE is reportedly interrogating Tribal citizens in Arizona and New Mexico.

Imagine if NCAI hadundertaken the workover the last four yearstohelp meaningfully defend these and any further assaults on Tribal citizenship and sovereignty.

Imagine if Indian country writ large was more intentional about Tribal citizenship protection vis-a-vis either Tribal or U.S. constitutionallaw. See "The Original Peoples Deserve Freedom" (2024)("Tribal citizens' right to belong as Americans is not even protected by the Fourteenth Amendment....Tribal citizens remain exempt from America's central promise."); "Tribal Nationhood Requires Civil Rights Protection" (2022) ("there is no national tribal organization...that advocates for the universal protection of Indigenous civil rights").

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

See More Popular Content From

Mondaq uses cookies on this website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Learn More