Contracts are legally binding agreements formed through mutual understanding and governed by established legal principles. Under the Indian Contract Act, 1872, a valid contract requires four essential elements: offer, acceptance, lawful consideration, and an intention to create legal relations. Conventionally, contracts rely on mutual agreement between parties and are enforced through legal review by lawyers and courts.
However, with the rapid growth of digital technologies and automation, this conventional model is undergoing a significant transformation. Among the key advancements in this domain is the smart contract, a self-executing digital agreement written in computer code that automatically performs specified actions when predetermined conditions are met.
For example, a smart contract may be programmed to release payment upon confirmation of goods delivery. By integrating performance mechanisms directly into the code, smart contracts eliminate the need for manual oversight or third-party enforcement, thereby enhancing improving efficiency, reducing costs, and minimizing potential for disputes.
Smart Contracts: A Technological Innovation
Smart contracts operate on blockchain platforms, which ensure that execution is transparent, secure, and resistant to unauthorized alteration. After the terms are encoded, the contract executes autonomously, without the need for further human involvement.
By eliminating third parties such as lawyers, brokers, or notaries, smart contracts reduce transaction costs and improve operational efficiency. Automated execution minimizes the risk of human error and delays. Each transaction is permanently recorded on the blockchain, ensuring transparency, and data integrity. These features make smart contracts particularly useful in sectors that demand precision, reliability, and trust.
Types of Smart Contracts
Smart contracts vary in form and function depending on their use case. They can generally be classified into three categories:
Smart Legal Contracts:
These incorporate legal terms into code and are commonly used in sectors like banking, insurance, and real estate. While certain functions are automated, they often retain a written legal text to remain enforceable under conventional laws, such as the Indian Contract Act, 1872.
Decentralized Autonomous Organizations (DAOs):
DAOs function through smart contracts on a blockchain, without any central authority. DAOs are commonly used in decentralized finance, a blockchain-based financial system that enables activities such as lending, trading, and investing without relying on traditional financial institutions, as well as on other blockchain platforms. DAO decisions are made collectively by members who vote using tokens, based on governance rules incorporated in the smart contract code. While DAOs are increasingly adopted worldwide, they currently lack legal recognition in India, with no specific regulatory framework governing them. Their legal status remains uncertain in most jurisdictions.
Application Logic Contracts (ALCs):
ALCs integrate with external systems and software to manage complex processes like supply chain logistics or enterprise automation. ALCs often connect to or use application programming interfaces to access real-world information. Despite generally lacking formal legal recognition, ALCs are essential for enabling large-scale implementation and seamless integration between blockchain networks and real-world system
Industry Use
Smart contracts are transforming key sectors. In legal services, they streamline routine agreements, boosting efficiency and accessibility. In healthcare, they enable secure, time-bound access to patient data, improving clinical decision-making. In supply chains, they provide end-to-end visibility and enforce standards by pausing movement when violations occur.
Advantages of Smart Contracts
Smart contracts offer significant advantages benefits over conventional agreements. Their automated execution eliminates the need for intermediaries, resulting in substantial savings in time and cost. Because performance is driven by code rather than trust, they reduce the risk of non-compliance. Well-defined terms provide clarity and limit the potential for disputes. Additionally, blockchain technology ensures that all transactions are secure, transparent, and independently auditable.
Legal and Technical Limitations
Despite their merits, smart contracts present key challenges that must be resolved to facilitate wider adoption and build trust One major concern is legal uncertainty, particularly in cross-border contexts, where questions of jurisdiction, applicable law, and dispute resolution remain unresolved. Additionally, their development requires specialised technical expertise, creating a dependency on developers for secure and reliable implementation. Privacy is also a concern, as information on public blockchains is visible to everyone unless protected through private or restricted-access networks. Furthermore, smart contracts are inherently rigid—unlike traditional agreements, they are difficult to amend, making the correction of errors or updates to terms difficult.
Smart Contracts Under Indian Law
Smart contracts are not expressly regulated under Indian law, but they can be valid if they meet the requirements of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 such as offer, acceptance, lawful consideration, and mutual consent. The Information Technology Act, 2000 (IT Act) complements this by recognizing electronic records and digital signatures. Section 10A affirms the enforceability of electronic contracts.
For legal recognition, smart contracts should ideally use digital signatures issued by licensed Certifying Authorities under the IT Act. Blockchain-based contracts that rely on cryptographic keys may not conform to the statutory definition of a digital signature under IT Act. This can affect their admissibility as evidence and their legal recognition in judicial proceedings this standard, potentially affecting their enforceability in court.
The Supreme Court's decision in Internet and Mobile Association of India v. Reserve Bank of India, (2020) 10 SCC 274, which set aside the RBI's 2018 circular prohibiting banking services for virtual currency entities, renewed national interest in blockchain, including smart contracts. Subsequently, Maharashtra and Telangana launched blockchain pilot projects for land record management and digital identity initiatives.
However, the absence of a comprehensive statutory framework, inadequate technical infrastructure, and limited public awareness continue to present significant challenges. To ensure legal certainty and broader adoption of smart contracts, India may require a robust regulatory framework addressing their creation, execution, enforceability, dispute resolution, and consumer protection.
Conclusion Aligning Law and Code for a Digital Future
Smart contracts represent a paradigm shift in the way agreements are prepared and executed in the digital era. While the technology offers considerable efficiency and reliability, its full potential will only be realized through clear legal recognition, robust regulatory frameworks, and public readiness.
In India, both digital infrastructure and regulatory reform are evolving, the way forward requires in harmonising the precision of code with the adaptability of legal systems. With careful alignment of law and technology, smart contracts can serve as powerful instruments for building a transparent, accountable, and efficient digital future.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
