Expropriation is an operation that allows the government or certain public entities designated by law to dispossess a person from part or all of their property without their consent.
In certain cases, this can mean that a person will lose his business, his buildings or his real estate development project. In other cases, expropriation may also result in the relocation of a business with all the resulting costs.
An Exceptional Procedure
The law is clear: private property is inviolable. The only exception to this rule is expropriation, a procedure considered necessary for the common good. However, and this is paramount, the compensation offered by the public authority must be fair. The courts are in agreement to define what is fair: the expropriated person is entitled to receive the highest market value for his property, taking into account the income that he receives or could receive from its optimal utilisation. So, you are not only entitled to the value of the real estate from which you are dispossessed, but often much more.
However, the offer made to you might not take into account the total value of your property. If this is the case, it would be highly advised or recommended to use a team of specialist lawyers who can demand a higher amount from the expropriating authorities. We have prepared the following frequently asked questions (FAQs) to help you stay informed about the most common questions on expropriation procedures.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
- What is the real impact of an expropriation procedure and the considerable consequences that such a procedure can have on people who are deprived of their property for the benefit of public interests?
- What constitutes a disguised expropriation and what are the criteria for qualifying disguised expropriation as such?
- Is the principle of full compensation respected when land is expropriated for housing development?
- How did the Vavilov judgment reshape the jurisprudence on the standard of review?
Q. What is the real impact of an expropriation procedure and the considerable consequences that such a procedure can have on people who are deprived of their property for the benefit of public interests?
Most people are familiar with the term 'expropriation'
from having heard it mentioned in the media in connection with
major projects. However, very few people understand the real scope
of expropriation and are therefore unaware of the considerable
consequences that such a procedure can have on the people who are
deprived of their property for the benefit of public interests.
Discover the basic concepts of expropriation as well as the key
elements to be aware of with regard to the procedure applicable to
this type of case.
Q. What constitutes a disguised expropriation and what are the criteria for qualifying disguised expropriation as such?
The concept of disguised expropriation in Quebec law is not new,
as the first relevant decisions on this subject were rendered in
the 1960s. As evidenced by the abundant amount of decisions in this
area, disguised expropriation is still fascinating today and the
guidelines for defining it do not seem to have become
Lean more (French only - English coming soon)
Q. Is the principle of full compensation respected when land is expropriated for housing development?
Usually a public body has the right to expropriate any owner,
but as this is an extraordinary and far-reaching power, it can only
do so in return for fair compensation. In recent years, the courts
have occasionally had to consider the expropriation of vacant land
for a housing development project.
Learn more (French only - English coming soon)
The rules governing appeals to the Court of Québec from a
decision of the Tribunal administratif du Québec
("TAQ") may seem, at first glance, simple and easy to
apply. Despite this simplicity of the vocabulary used by the
legislator, the reader will note that the implementation of this
appeal has seen two divergent positions imposed over the
Learn more (French only - English coming soon)
Expropriation is a specialized field that is governed by a particular set of rules. Supported by one of the largest litigation and real estate law practice groups in Canada, our team combines the necessary experience with in-depth knowledge of the processes to successfully conclude the most complex expropriation cases.
Whether your case is simple or complex, we are equipped to represent your interests. We take a pragmatic approach with the aim of settling your cases in the most beneficial way for you.
Our services cover all aspects of expropriation, whether challenging a notice of reservation or a notice of expropriation, or seeking full compensation. We support expropriated persons at every stage of the process and help them make the best decisions, quickly and efficiently.
We also have an extensive network of contacts that allows us to collaborate with eminent experts who are fully available to you (real estate and business appraisers, engineers, urban planners, architects, etc.).
Representative mandates and precedent-setting decisions
Our group currently represents more than $1 billion in assets owned by businesses and corporations of all sizes. We serve companies such as Cadillac Fairview, Broccolini, Québecor, Nissan, Brault and Martineau, Metro, Jean Coutu and Redbourne, as well as investment funds, warehousing and transport companies, distributors, builders and retailers.
The business ties that exist between Fasken and its many clients, including Intramodal, Webster, Groupe Hypertec, Jubilant Draxlmage and Parasuco Jeans, demonstrate our ability to represent you in a variety of complex disputes.
Here are some examples of mandates that we have recently concluded:
- An out-of-court settlement concludes the $66.3 million lawsuit filed by developer Aldo Coviello against the City of Laval
- Expropriation matter for Cadillac Fairview Limited Corporation and Ivanhoé Cambridge Inc. as part of the blue line extension project of the Société de transport de Montréal
- XTL Transport in a dispute with Hydro-Québec regarding the acquisition of a servitude for passage of a power line
- Ville de Lorraine v. 2646-8926 Québec inc
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.