ARTICLE
17 January 2025

Clause For Celebration: The Effectiveness Of Entire Agreement Provisions

AO
A&O Shearman

Contributor

A&O Shearman was formed in 2024 via the merger of two historic firms, Allen & Overy and Shearman & Sterling. With nearly 4,000 lawyers globally, we are equally fluent in English law, U.S. law and the laws of the world’s most dynamic markets. This combination creates a new kind of law firm, one built to achieve unparalleled outcomes for our clients on their most complex, multijurisdictional matters – everywhere in the world. A firm that advises at the forefront of the forces changing the current of global business and that is unrivalled in its global strength. Our clients benefit from the collective experience of teams who work with many of the world’s most influential companies and institutions, and have a history of precedent-setting innovations. Together our lawyers advise more than a third of NYSE-listed businesses, a fifth of the NASDAQ and a notable proportion of the London Stock Exchange, the Euronext, Euronext Paris and the Tokyo and Hong Kong Stock Exchanges.
The court in JMW Solicitors v Injury Lawyers 4U reaffirmed the enforceability of entire agreement clauses, emphasizing their ability to supersede prior agreements and bar claims of estoppel from pre-contractual representations. JMW's claims were dismissed as unsustainable.
United Kingdom Corporate/Commercial Law

Entire agreement clauses are very common. This recent decision confirms their effectiveness: JMW Solicitors v Injury Lawyers 4U.

Background – shareholder dispute

Some firms of solicitors, including JMW, set up a company, Injury Lawyers 4U. The original shareholders' agreement was amended by a supplemental deed to change the price of participation depending on whether you were a founding shareholder or a new panel member. A new shareholders' agreement, entered into some time later, made no mention of this price differential and contained an entire agreement clause. When, some time later, the directors formally stopped applying the differential pricing, JMW and others sued. Their case was put as breach of the original shareholders' agreement (as amended by the supplemental deed), breach of the deed on its own as a collateral warranty, or, alternatively, estoppel by convention. They sought a declaration that the differential pricing still applied. Injury Lawyers 4U applied for summary judgment, relying on the entire agreement provision in the new shareholders' agreement, saying JMW had no reasonable prospect of success.

The effectiveness of an entire agreement clause

The court held that any argument that the provision in the supplemental deed superseded the new shareholders' agreement was "hopeless". The court referred to:

  • The clear and unambiguous language used stating that the new shareholders' agreement constituted "the whole agreement".
  • The explicit reference to the fact that the new shareholders' agreement "supersedes any previous arrangement, understanding or agreement between them".
  • The recitals in the new shareholders' agreement indicating the parties' intention to consolidate and update previous agreements "in their entirety".
  • What it discerned was the parties' objective intention.

The entire agreement clause was also effective to defeat the claim of estoppel based on pre-contractual representations. For post-contractual representations you would look to a non-oral modification clause.

The court also did not accept that JMW had any prospect of being able to rectify the new shareholders' agreement. Fundamentally, the court did not accept that what the directors had done was any more than exercise their discretion to continue the price differential for a period while being under no legal obligation to continue to do so.

Judgment: JMW Solicitors v Injury Lawyers 4U

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Mondaq uses cookies on this website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Learn More