- within Family and Matrimonial topic(s)
- with Senior Company Executives, HR and Finance and Tax Executives
- in United States
- with readers working within the Accounting & Consultancy, Banking & Credit and Healthcare industries
When high-income couples separate, determining child and spousal support amounts becomes more complex than in typical cases. In Canada, the Federal Child Support Guidelines (FCSG) and Spousal Support Advisory Guidelines (SSAG) provide frameworks for support. However, incomes over $150,000 raise unique issues involving lifestyle, extraordinary expenses, and complex financial structures.
Child Support and High Incomes
The FCSG offer straightforward tables up to $150,000 of income which, for the most part, are not deviated from. For higher incomes, the tables no longer directly apply and courts use discretion to set amounts that are determined to be fair. Judges may require payments above the table values, considering the child's needs, the pre-separation lifestyle, and the paying parent's financial capacity, or may go below the table values if the child's needs are being equally maintained in both households.
Key challenges include:
- Extraordinary Expenses: High-income families may incur costs like private school, international travel, or specialized activities. Determining whether these are “reasonable” or necessary can be contentious, especially if they reflect a lifestyle rather than a need.
- Complex Income Sources: High earners often have corporate income, dividends, bonuses, and/or investments. Courts must assess total income, sometimes imputing income if a parent underreports by minimizing salary or claiming business deductions from which they derived a personal benefit.
Spousal Support and High Incomes
Spousal support calculations also become nuanced at high income levels. While the SSAGs offer guidance, courts must balance fairness with practicality, taking into consideration the specific facts of the parties before them.
Key considerations include:
- Ability to Pay vs. Need for Support: Courts weigh income disparities and the marital standard of living against whether the recipient truly needs substantial ongoing support.
- Short-Term vs. Long-Term Support: Courts decide whether support should bridge a spouse towards independence or continue long term. If one spouse left the workforce or was accustomed to a luxurious lifestyle beyond what their own income can support, longer spousal support may be justified, regardless of the duration of the parties' relationship. However, courts also consider the recipient's potential to become financially self-sufficient with an obligation on both spouses to try and maximize their earning potential.
Why These Cases Are Complex
Support calculations for high earners often require detailed financial analysis beyond the standard guidelines. Corporate structures, investment portfolios, and tax strategies can obscure true income. Courts may disregard reported figures and focus instead on actual economic benefit.
Similarly, lifestyle-based claims, such as maintaining private schooling or luxury travel, can spark disputes over what constitutes a child's “reasonable needs” or a spouse's entitlement post-separation.
Given these complexities, professional guidance is essential. Family lawyers ensure that legal rules and case law are applied correctly, while financial experts such as accountants and business valuators help assess total income and asset structures. Without expert input, high-income earners risk unfair obligations or incomplete settlements.
Conclusion
Child and spousal support for incomes over $150,000 present challenges not seen in typical cases. Courts must balance children's needs, pre-separation lifestyles, and financial realities while working outside the standard guidelines. For spousal support, questions of duration, fairness, and independence further complicate matters.
High-income cases demand tailored solutions, often requiring both legal and financial expertise. If you are navigating support obligations at this level, consulting an experienced family lawyer is essential to ensure fair and accurate outcomes.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
