ARTICLE
14 October 2024

Protests in Sydney: balancing freedom and security

OC
O'Brien Criminal & Civil Solicitors

Contributor

O’Brien Criminal and Civil Solicitors defend people against criminal charges anywhere in Australia, as well as litigating defamation cases, and suing police and other authorities for unlawful conduct. We are a strong advocate for social justice issues and pride ourselves on our pro-bono practice. We are a growing and dynamic law firm that occasionally has vacancies for people seeking legal careers or administrative opportunities.
The delicate balance between the right to protest and public safety has come under scrutiny in Australia.
Australia Criminal Law

In recent events, the delicate balance between the right to protest and public safety has come under scrutiny in Australia. Two incidents highlight the complexities surrounding protest laws and their enforcement. Let's explore the recent protests in Sydney.

Pro-Palestine Protests in Sydney

The New South Wales Police Force faced a legal challenge when they attempted to prohibit a pro-Palestine protest planned for Sydney's CBD. The Supreme Court ruled against the police, allowing the demonstration to proceed. This decision underscores the importance of protecting the right to peaceful assembly and free speech, even in contentious situations.

Hezbollah Flag Controversy

In a separate incident, tensions arose when a man was arrested for displaying a Hezbollah flag during a protest in Sydney. The arrest occurred amidst heightened concerns over the Israel-Lebanon conflict. This event raises questions about the limits of expression during protests and the role of law enforcement in maintaining public order while respecting individual rights.

Legal Framework of protests in Sydney

Australia's approach to protest rights involves a delicate balance:

Freedom of Assembly: The right to peaceful protest is generally protected under Australian law.

Public Safety: Authorities have the power to impose restrictions on protests to ensure public safety and order.

Prohibited Symbols: Some jurisdictions have laws against displaying symbols associated with terrorist organizations.

Challenges and Considerations

The recent events highlight several key issues:

  1. Balancing Rights: How to protect the right to protest while addressing security concerns.
  2. Consistency in Enforcement: Ensuring that protest laws are applied fairly and consistently.
  3. Cultural Sensitivity: Navigating complex geopolitical issues in a multicultural society.

As Australia continues to grapple with these challenges, the ongoing dialogue between law enforcement, the judiciary, and civil society remains crucial in shaping the future of protest rights in the country.

Fines and Imprisonment

The penalties for violating protest laws can be quite severe in some cases:

  • In New South Wales, obstructing traffic during a protest can result in fines of up to 4 penalty units.
  • South Australia has introduced harsh penalties of up to $50,000 or 3 months imprisonment for obstructing a public place.
  • In Tasmania, laws targeting environmental protests carry penalties of up to $10,000 and four years' imprisonment.
  • New South Wales passed laws with fines of up to $5,500 for unlawful entry on land that interferes with business operations.

Specific Protest Offences

Common charges associated with protests include:

  • Obstructing traffic or public places.
  • Resisting or hindering police (up to 12 months imprisonment or 10 penalty units fine in NSW).
  • Assaulting police (up to 5-7 years imprisonment in NSW),
  • Interfering with mines or forestry operations.
  • Violent disorder (up to 10-15 years imprisonment in Victoria).
  • Property damage.

Expanded Police Powers for Protests in Sydney

Many anti-protest laws grant police broader discretionary powers to:

  • Shut down protests obstructing traffic.
  • Direct protesters to leave certain areas.
  • Arrest protesters for minor disruptions to businesses.

Constitutional Challenges

Some anti-protest laws have faced constitutional challenges for potentially violating the implied freedom of political communication in the Australian Constitution. However, many restrictive laws remain in effect.

Chilling Effect on Free Speech

While not a direct legal consequence, the harsh penalties and expanded police powers are seen by some as having a chilling effect on legitimate protest and free speech.

In summary, violating protest laws in Australia can result in significant fines, potential imprisonment, and expanded police powers to shut down or restrict protests, with penalties varying by state and specific offence. The laws have been criticized for their potential to unduly restrict freedom of assembly and political expression.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Mondaq uses cookies on this website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Learn More