A virtual hearing can be challenging for any regulatory lawyer. It requires relying on technology more than ever to advocate for clients. It can feel like talking to an empty room, even if you're on camera. Plus it requires attorneys to get results for our clients without the benefit of interpersonal contact with the judge, commissioners or staff. However, having survived my first virtual evidentiary hearing before a state energy commission in April 2020 – and with the benefit of hindsight – it's like everything lawyers do for the first time in our practice: It's a challenge until you do it. And like the first oral argument we made or the first hearing we ever litigated, we learn lessons and improve each time.
We will likely face more than a few virtual hearings given the current pandemic and shelter-in-place orders. Currently, many state regulatory agencies have postponed evidentiary hearings or scheduled briefs and telephonic oral arguments to narrow the issues requiring hearings. But that can only last so long, given that utilities, power grid operators, pipelines and other energy companies have to continue doing business as essential services.
The following are some practical tips I learned to manage the challenges of a virtual hearing:
- Schedule time to prepare your office setup at home. Is your workstation sufficiently comfortable for you to sit for hours at a stretch and access documents quickly? You may want to check whether your printer works well enough not to jam when printing more than five pages in a pinch. You will want to make sure you are well placed away from distractions such as family and pets. You may also want to use a wide table to set up your papers and laptop(s) (I found more than one useful – one for typing and accessing documents, and the other purely for the camera). It also helps to check your Wi-Fi connection to minimize the likelihood of disconnections during the hearing. And don't forget to download the application to be used for the hearing and test it a day or two before the hearing.
- Ask the judge ahead of time to schedule a prehearing conference for the parties to discuss procedures at the hearing. It helps to know ahead of time whether you will need to register or download applications for the hearing, whether there will be telephone or videoconference access, how the commission will handle public accessibility to the hearing, and how to share documents or present slides.
- If your client and other parties are willing, you may ask the judge if the commission is comfortable with the parties splitting the costs to use a more stable online platform for the hearing to minimize the risk of technical glitches. It also helps to ask that everyone, including commissioners, counsel and the judge, turn on their video capabilities to see facial expressions, body language and pair voices with faces. Video is useful for cross examining witnesses, but it may not be useful if you are defending a witness who does not present well on camera.
- Strategize in advance with the parties and judge on how to handle marking exhibits, and if possible, mark as many exhibits as possible in advance. Have ready at your fingertips any exhibits you need to introduce in rebuttal at the hearing, and arrange with the judge in advance how those exhibits will be transmitted to the court reporter and circulated to all counsel.
- Energy regulatory agency hearings often involve multiple parties. Strategize with the parties and judge ahead of time on the order in which each party will present their case. It is also useful for the court reporter if you plan ahead of time how you will indicate that you are finished speaking about an issue, so people do not speak over each other very often. (For example, during my hearing, each person who spoke would say "over" at the end of their statement to indicate they had finished.)
- Raise due process concerns as early as possible. Strategize with the judge on how witness cross examination and commissioner questions will be handled, how objections will be handled, and how parties must not email or text their witnesses while the witnesses are on the virtual "stand."
- Strategize with the judge and parties ahead of time on how to handle technical glitches and unforeseen interruptions, such as when a party drops off the videoconference or phone line inadvertently, or cannot be heard when trying to unmute the line, or echoes occur, among other interruptions.
- Strategize in advance how you can confer offline with your client, your witness or co-parties' counsel in sidebar conferences during the hearing. You may want to make sure you have more than one phone in the room, or a separate laptop with a separate videoconference set up for strategy meetings during breaks.
- During the hearing, take a longer than usual pause after speaking to allow for questions from the judge or commissioners. Prepare your witnesses to do the same in case you need to state an objection. Sometimes it takes longer to unmute yourself and speak than if you were in a hearing room.
- Expect that delays and glitches may happen. Nothing compares to the experience of human interaction in a hearing room. It may help to request the Judge in advance whether the parties will have the opportunity to submit briefs after the hearing, or to allow time for counsel to prepare opening and closing statements to promote due process.
Each regulatory agency has different preferences and rules, so it always helps to familiarize yourself with the evolving rules for remote hearings.
Originally published May 1, 2020
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.