Introduction
Sustainable finance integrates environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors into investment decisions to foster long-term growth. In India, ESG investing is gaining momentum due to increasing awareness of climate risks, social issues, and governance standards. However, despite the growth in sustainable finance, the market faces significant challenges such as regulatory hurdles, insufficient disclosure practices, and the rising threat of fraud, that can erode investor confidence.
ESG Investing in India and types of Sustainable Investments
India has demonstrated evident economic resilience to the prevailing global challenges like climate change, inflation, COVID-19 pandemic, armed conflicts, and supply chain disruptions. In total, six ESG funds were introduced in India between 2012 and 2020; recent data shows the country has 11 sustainable investment funds. These consist of eight actively managed funds, one passive fund (ETF/Funds of Funds), and two global feeder funds. Managed funds continue to be the strong-hold that dominates this space as their AUM accounts for the lions' share, coming in at 96% and with five fund houses accounting for more than 93% of that entire figure. The largest one made up nearly 56% of the overall AUM figure1.
In 2021, India issued the Business Responsibility and Sustainability Report (BRSR) of the Securities and Exchange Board of India, which mandates the top 1,000 listed companies to report sustainability-related information. BRSR Core applies to the top 150 companies, demanding third-party assurance by their FY24 annual report. It is expected to scale up to 250 more by FY25 and then cover the full 1,000 by FY27.
ESG investment has increased remarkably over the last two years in India, positioning itself as a key avenue for long-term growth. This shift is driven by increasing confidence in the products being introduced to the market, which are aligned with ESG principles. As businesses and investment firms develop products that address sustainability and ethical governance, investors are seeing more transparent, well-defined, and measurable ESG criteria. Furthermore, many companies are embedding ESG principles into their core business strategies, making them not only attractive investments but also models of long-term resilience. As a result, investors are becoming more confident that these ESG-aligned products offer sustainable, profitable opportunities while also contributing positively to environmental and social causes. This evolving market landscape is creating a feedback loop where growing investor confidence in ESG products fuels further innovation and deeper commitment to sustainability across industries.
Types of Sustainable Investments
Green Bonds and Renewable Energy Projects - Green bonds are fixed-income securities used specifically to finance environmental projects, such as renewable energy projects. For businesses, issuing green bonds allows access to capital specifically earmarked for renewable energy projects like solar farms and wind turbines. On the investor side, these bonds represent a steady income stream while promoting environmental stewardship. International investors are also increasingly recognizing India's renewable energy initiatives, which are poised to offer robust returns as the country expands its clean energy capacity.
Impact Investing - Impact investing is a global phenomenon, gaining traction in markets from Europe to North America and Asia and aims to achieve measurable social or environmental outcomes combined with financial returns. This type of investment targets areas such as renewable energy access, water conservation, and social enterprises that address inequality.
ESG Integration - ESG integration adds ESG factors into traditional financial analysis. Investors typically assess companies based on standard financial metrics such as revenue, profitability, and growth prospects. However, with ESG integration, they also evaluate a company's performance in areas like environmental stewardship, social responsibility, and governance practices. By doing so, investors gain a fuller understanding of the opportunities and risks associated with a company's ESG practices, which can directly impact its long-term performance and resilience.
For example, a company that effectively manages its carbon footprint and adopts strong labour practices may be better positioned for long-term success, both in terms of financial returns and risk mitigation. Conversely, companies with weak governance structures or poor environmental management may face reputational damage, regulatory penalties, or operational disruptions, which could harm their financial stability. By incorporating these ESG factors into financial analysis, investors ensure that sustainability considerations are an integral part of all investment decisions.
Thematic and Index-Based Investing - Thematic investing focuses on a set of sustainability issues or sectors, such as clean energy, gender equity, or healthcare innovation. Investors select companies focused on specific challenges; in contrast, index-based investments track sustainability indexes, such as the MSCI or Dow Jones Sustainability Index. These indexes rate the performance of companies on ESG and direct investors to support firms with improved sustainability performance.
Sustainability-Linked Bonds (SLBs) - SLBs are becoming increasingly popular, as they tie the cost of borrowing to the achievement of predefined ESG targets. For investors, SLBs offer an innovative way to support businesses that are serious about meeting their sustainability goals while benefiting from competitive returns. For businesses, these bonds serve as a way to raise capital while incentivizing sustainability performance. Meeting sustainability targets results in better financial terms, which can lower borrowing costs and enhance a company's reputation as a leader in corporate responsibility.
ESG Fraud On Sustainable Investors:
ESG fraud, often referred to as greenwashing, poses a significant threat to investors, as it involves misleading or exaggerated claims about the company's ESG practices. In such cases, businesses present themselves as "eco-friendly" or "sustainable," despite lacking any verifiable evidence to support their claims, or they inflate ESG data, such as carbon emissions reductions or social impact achievements.
Another aspect of ESG fraud happens when marketing messages don't reflect actual business practices. For example, a company might advertise itself as environmentally conscious, but its operations are still heavily reliant on fossil fuels or its supply chain practices don't meet sustainability standards. This disconnect creates a growing distrust of ESG claims, complicating the decision-making process for investors who want to make informed, values-driven choices.
The consequences of ESG fraud extend beyond financial losses for investors. It undermines the fundamental goals of sustainability, such as combating climate change and addressing social inequality. By misallocating capital away from truly impactful initiatives, these fraudulent practices hinder progress and erode confidence in sustainable investing. In the long term, ESG fraud damages both the integrity of the market and the broader movement toward sustainability.
The Role of Legal Advisors in ESG Investments
Legal advisors play a pertinent role in ensuring that ESG investments meet all legal and regulatory requirements. Conducting thorough due diligence is essential to verify the authenticity of ESG claims made by companies, ensuring that they are not merely "greenwashing" – here, legal professionals assess whether businesses comply with relevant regulations, such as SEBI's sustainability reporting standards, and ensure that ESG practices are genuinely embedded in operations.
By leveraging established ESG frameworks and conducting detailed reviews of a company's sustainability practices, legal advisors help prevent investors from falling victim to fraudulent schemes. Their role is crucial in navigating the complexities of the evolving ESG regulatory landscape, providing both compliance assurance and peace of mind that investments are truly contributing to meaningful, long-term environmental and social impact.
Conclusion
In conclusion, while sustainable finance and ESG investing present significant opportunities for long-term, socially responsible investments, the rise of ESG fraud poses serious risks to both investors and the integrity of the market. As demand for ESG investments grows, investors need to scrutinize companies' ESG claims and regulators must strengthen oversight mechanisms. Only through transparency and accountability can sustainable investing truly contribute to the global goals of addressing climate change, social inequality, and other critical challenges.
Footnote
1 IBEF, 2023. ESG investing in India: Navigating environmental, social, and governance factors for sustainable growth. [online] Available at: https://www.ibef.org/blogs/esg-investing-in-india-navigating-environmental-social-and-governance-factors-for-sustainable-growth [Accessed 15 January 2025].
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
