Last month we wrote about some of the proposed class actions in the United States in the wake of COVID-19. As we noted then, class actions in the United States create a risk of "copycat" claims in Canada—and there is always a risk of similar claims in both jurisdictions. Far more proposed class actions related to COVID-19 have been filed in the United States since our last update. Many relate to consumer protection issues and consumer contracts—for example:

  1. several class actions complaints have been filed against businesses—including gyms and amusement parks—that allegedly continued to charge monthly fees to consumers while their facilities are closed in response to COVID-19;
  2. a class action complaint has been filed in relation to cancelled events where tickets were allegedly not refunded; and
  3. class action complaints have been filed against several universities for allegedly not refunding certain amounts after campuses were closed or services were suspended;

Proposed class actions have also been filed by businesses and others against governments and related entities based on their responses to COVID-19. For example:

  1. employees of the US government have filed a class action complaint seeking hazard pay for working in close proximity to individuals or objects infected with COVID-19;
  2. a business in Pennsylvania has filed a class action complaint alleging that orders closing non-essential businesses are unconstitutional; and
  3. a class action complaint has been filed against the People's Republic of China and related entities alleging a negligent response to the virus.

These examples demonstrate the ongoing risks class actions to businesses (and governments) as they respond to COVID-19. In particular, they suggest that consumer protection claims may follow when businesses do not offer refunds for services they cannot provide due to COVID-19. Similar class actions may be filed in Canada.

For more information about the content of this update, please contact one of the authors, and for up-to-date information on COVID-19 and McCarthy Tétrault's perspective on the legal issues it presents, please visit our dedicated hub here.

To view the original article please click here.

Originally published 21 April 2020

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.