- with Senior Company Executives, HR and Finance and Tax Executives
- with readers working within the Property and Law Firm industries
Negotiating with an ex can be emotionally charged and exhausting, but the way those conversations are handled can significantly affect how quickly issues are resolved and how much conflict is created along the way.
Introduction
Whether discussions are about financial issues or parenting matters, negotiating with an ex is rarely straightforward. Old emotions, unresolved grievances and mistrust can easily resurface and derail even simple conversations. Without a clear approach, discussions can become reactive, circular and deeply stressful.
This article sets out practical general strategies to help you negotiate more effectively with your ex, regardless of the specific issue involved.
Get clear on your objectives before you engage
Many negotiations fail before they begin because people start talking without a clear sense of what they are trying to achieve.
Before engaging with your ex, take time to identify your priorities. Decide what outcomes are essential, what you would strongly prefer and where you can afford to be flexible. Writing these down helps you stay focused when tensions rise and prevents you from agreeing to things you later regret.
It is also important to understand why each issue matters to you. Having a clear internal rationale makes it easier to stay calm and consistent, even when discussions become difficult.
Choose the right communication method
How you communicate can be just as important as what you communicate.
Written communication, such as email or messaging, often provides the most control. It allows time to think before responding, reduces emotional escalation and creates a clear record of what has been said. Phone calls and in-person discussions can be useful where there is mutual respect, but they can quickly become confrontational if there is a history of conflict.
If past discussions have escalated easily, written communication is usually the safer and more effective choice, outside of third-party dispute resolution options.
Set and enforce clear boundaries
You cannot control how your ex behaves, but you can control how and when you engage.
Clear boundaries include limiting how frequently you respond, restricting communication to specific topics, or refusing to engage with abusive or inflammatory language. Boundaries only work if they are consistently enforced. Continuing to respond after a boundary has been crossed often reinforces the behaviour you are trying to stop.
Setting boundaries early helps prevent negotiations from becoming overwhelming or emotionally draining.
Keep communication structured and focused
Emotionally-charged discussions tend to become unproductive when messages are long, unfocused or cover multiple issues at once.
Keeping communication structured helps maintain clarity. Focus on one issue at a time, clearly state your proposal, briefly explain your reasoning and identify what you want to happen next. Avoid unnecessary detail and resist the temptation to revisit unrelated disputes.
Clear structure reduces misunderstandings and makes it easier to move discussions forward.
Separate the problem from the person
It is common to feel that your ex is the source of the difficulty. However, framing negotiations around blame or personal criticism usually leads to defensiveness rather than progress.
Where possible, focus on the practical issue rather than the individual. Neutral language and a problem-solving mindset help keep discussions focused on outcomes rather than personal conflict. This approach does not excuse past behaviour, but it does increase the chances of productive dialogue.
Avoid negotiating the past
Negotiations with an ex often stall when they turn into debates about what happened during the relationship.
While those feelings may be understandable, practical negotiations are rarely the place to resolve them. Re-litigating the past tends to inflame emotions and distract from what needs to be decided now.
Bringing discussions back to current and future arrangements is usually far more effective.
Anticipate emotional triggers and plan your response
Communication with an ex can trigger strong emotional reactions, even long after separation. Planning for this in advance can prevent impulsive responses that escalate conflict.
Strategies may include delaying responses to upsetting messages, drafting replies and reviewing them later, or limiting how often you check communications. Responding only to the substance of a message, rather than its tone, can also keep discussions on track.
A useful test is whether you would be comfortable with a neutral third party reading your response.
Trade concessions rather than giving ground
Negotiation is about exchange, not one-sided compromise.
If you agree to something important to your ex, consider what you need in return. Framing discussions around mutual concessions helps maintain balance and reduces resentment. It also discourages repeated demands by reinforcing that agreement involves give and take on both sides.
Use objective reference points where possible
Disputes often arise because each person is using a different standard for what is reasonable.
Referring to objective factors such as schedules, financial realities, work commitments or professional advice can help ground discussions in practical reality. Objective reference points reduce personal conflict and make positions easier to explain without escalating tension.
Recognise unproductive patterns early
Certain patterns commonly derail negotiations, including pressure to make immediate decisions, shifting topics to avoid resolution, or presenting issues as all-or-nothing.
Recognising these behaviours early allows you to slow the conversation down and redirect it back to the issue that needs to be resolved, rather than reacting emotionally.
Know when to pause or seek support
Not every negotiation benefits from continued direct communication. If discussions become hostile, repetitive or emotionally overwhelming, pausing can be a strategic choice rather than a failure.
Mediation, counselling support or professional advice can introduce structure and reduce conflict. Seeking support early often prevents issues from escalating and protects your wellbeing.
When negotiation is not appropriate
In some situations, particularly where there is intimidation, coercive behaviour or safety concerns, direct negotiation may not be appropriate at all.
In those circumstances, prioritising safety is critical. This may involve limiting communication, using intermediaries or obtaining urgent professional assistance.
Conclusion
Negotiating with an ex is rarely easy, but a clear plan, strong boundaries and structured communication can significantly reduce conflict and stress. Focusing on practical outcomes and knowing when to seek support can help prevent negotiations from becoming damaging or prolonged.
If you need assistance negotiating with your ex, please contact one of our experienced family lawyers.
Cooper Grace Ward is a leading Australian law firm based in Brisbane.
This publication is for information only and is not legal advice. You should obtain advice that is specific to your circumstances and not rely on this publication as legal advice. If there are any issues you would like us to advise you on arising from this publication, please contact Cooper Grace Ward Lawyers.
