Kim Wood, Associate Director of WTW's P&I team, talks about the P&I market in the wake of the Baltimore harbour disaster.
Global Marine market trends
Hear from our experts and learn more about the latest insurance marketplace trends.
To view the video please click here.
Transcript:
Global Marketplace Insights – Marine Q3 2024
0:03
SPEAKER: Welcome to WTW's Global Marketplace Insights series,
where our experts bring you the latest risk and insurance
perspectives.
0:21
KIM WOOD: Hello. My name is Kim Wood, and I'm an associate
director in WTW's P&I team. In the next three minutes,
I'm going to try to give you a condensed overview of the
P&I market and the easiest place to start is last year.
0:35
So last year, as of the 20th of February 2024, we have a full set
of reporting accounts from all the clubs in the international
group, and they're pretty positive. The market overall looks
reasonably good, with the average market combined ratio sitting at
96%, improved from 99% the previous year. The average market
investment income is 6.6%, which is particularly encouraging after
the investment losses seen in the previous year.
1:01
Combining the two, the positive underwriting and the positive
investment results, has driven free reserves for the market up by
15%. So largely a very promising situation. It's almost the
strongest the market's ever been. The highest point actually
being at the end of the 2017/18 policy year. But as you can see,
it's a favorable result nonetheless.
1:20
So that brings us neatly on to the current year. The event that has
dominated the headlines this year has been the Dali incident. This
is the container ship that hit the Baltimore bridge on the 26th of
March, 2024. A tragic incident which caused the bridge to collapse,
resulting in six people being killed, and with enormous
consequences as a result.
1:38
From a marine perspective, there's established case law in the
US that limits liability, and also limits the amount of
consequential damages payable by the ship, but it's going to be
an enormous claim, possibly the largest ever.
1:50
The largest ever P&I claim to date was the Costa Concordia,
which struck a rock and sank in 2012, and which 10 years ago cost
the industry $1.5 billion. There is a chance we may see the Dali
claim also reach this 1.5 billion level.
2:04
Although the Dali claim dominates the year, the P&I market is
resilient, and the claim will be paid and the market will carry on.
There will be increases in reinsurance costs and in premiums, but
they're not going to be something that kills the industry.
It's something that is an every 10-year event, or an event that
is containable within the industry.
2:22
The other thing about the current policy year is that the Dali
somehow masks that there has been nine other pool claims in the
first half of this year, which is marginally above the market
average for the first half of the year, and is significantly higher
than the last three years. So we have a higher incidence of
significantly large claims in the current year.
2:40
About a third of the international group P&I clubs indicate
what their results look like at the half-year point, 20th of
August. And from this half year view, it looks like a picture where
some clubs have had the big claims, and some clubs haven't,
some have combined ratios of 110%, and some still 90% combined
ratios.
2:58
Thus, as you can see, we have a very interesting renewal coming up.
And if you need to know more about the renewal and what to expect,
I'd recommend that you talk to your local marine client
advocate, and they'll be able to fill you in on the details of
that.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
