ARTICLE
21 January 2025

Litigation In Malta

GA
Ganado Advocates

Contributor

Ganado Advocates is a leading commercial law firm with a particular focus on the corporate, financial services and maritime/aviation sectors, predominantly servicing international clients doing business through Malta. The firm also promotes other areas such as tax, pensions, intellectual property, employment and litigation.
The Maltese legal system has developed into a mixed legal system. In private law matters, it is largely a jurisdiction based on the civil law tradi tion; however, decades of British rule exposed...
Malta Litigation, Mediation & Arbitration

1. General

1.1 General Characteristics of the Legal System

The Maltese legal system has developed into a mixed legal system. In private law matters, it is largely a jurisdiction based on the civil law tradi tion; however, decades of British rule exposed the Maltese legal system to English law in vari ous aspects of public law and the law of civil and criminal procedure. Consequently, many branches of contemporary Maltese law are influ enced by English law, ranging from public law to company law, fiscal law and maritime law.

The legal system primarily follows the adver sarial model, but there is some flexibility for judges to intervene at various stages, although not typically in an inquisitorial manner as is the case in most continental European jurisdictions. The legal process is generally conducted in both written and oral form.

1.2 Court System

The Maltese courts are divided into the Superior and Inferior Courts. In view of the size of the country, the judicial system is not split between federal and state courts.

Superior Courts

The Superior Courts consist of the Civil Court, the Court of Appeal and the Constitutional Court.

Civil Court

The Civil Court of superior jurisdiction hears all cases, except where competence has been vested in another court or tribunal, and in prin ciple, where the monetary value of the claim exceeds EUR15,000 or cannot be quantified when filing the lawsuit. The Superior Courts of criminal jurisdiction deal with criminal offences where punishment ranges from over six months up to life imprisonment.

The First Hall of the Civil Court is generally vest ed with competence to determine claims of a civil and commercial nature, and is divided into four sections:

  • the general jurisdiction;
  • the commercial section;
  • the family section; and
  • the voluntary jurisdiction section.

Court of Appeal

The Court of Appeal hears and determines all appeals from judgments of the Civil Court and the Court of Magistrates (Gozo) in its superior jurisdiction, and for this purpose is presided over by three judges.

Constitutional Court

The Constitutional Court acts as a first instance court in two instances:

  • where any question arises as to the member ship of the House of Representatives; and
  • if the Electoral Commission suspends the electoral process.

It also has appellate jurisdiction in a variety of circumstances, as follows:

  • in the case of appeals from decisions of the First Hall of the Civil Court on matters of human rights and fundamental freedoms;
  • in the case of appeals from decisions of any court of original jurisdiction affecting the inter pretation of the Constitution, other than on a matter of human rights; and
  • in the case of appeals as to the validity of laws, other than on a matter of human rights.

Inferior Courts

The Inferior Courts are the Court of Magistrates (Malta) and the Court of Magistrates (Gozo). They are vested with competence to hear and determine all monetary claims of an amount which exceeds EUR5,000, but does not exceed EUR15,000. All monetary claims of an amount not exceeding EUR5,000 are heard and deter mined by the Small Claims Tribunal.

The Court of Appeal also hears and determines appeals from the Inferior Courts; the Court of Appeal in its inferior jurisdiction is presided over by one judge for this purpose.

The laws of Malta also establish the following specialised tribunals to hear and determine dis putes of a special commercial nature:

  • the Financial Services Tribunal, which is set up by the Malta Financial Services Authority Act (Chapter 330 of the Laws of Malta), and is vested with the competence to determine disputes in relation to decisions made by the Malta Financial Services Authority;
  • the Public Contracts Review Board, which is set up by the Public Procurement Regula tions (Subsidiary Legislation 601.03), and determines remedies provided for in Maltese public procurement law, including challeng ing procurement procedures, challenging decisions made by contracting authorities, and challenging contracts which have been entered into illegally by contracting authori ties;
  • the Financial Services Arbiter, which is estab lished under the Arbiter for Financial Ser vices Act (Chapter 555 of the Laws of Malta), and hears complaints lodged by aggrieved investors against licensed financial services providers;
  • the Industrial Tribunal, which is set up by the Employment and Industrial Relations Act (Chapter 452 of the Laws of Malta), and is vested with the competence to determine certain cases relating to a set of employment relations issues and all cases of alleged unfair dismissals from employment;
  • the Administrative Review Tribunal, which is established by the Administrative Justice Act (Chapter 490 of the Laws of Malta) for the purpose of reviewing administrative acts by the public administration (ie, the government of Malta including its ministries and depart ments, local authorities, and any body corpo rate established by law of any order, licence, permit, warrant, authorisation, concession, decision, or refusal to any demand of a mem ber of the public). Any party to the proceed ings before the tribunal who feels aggrieved by a decision of this tribunal may appeal to the Court of Appeal, sitting in either its supe rior or its inferior jurisdiction. Administrative acts that do not fall in the competence of the Administrative Review Tribunal are reviewed by the First Hall of the Civil Court, composed of one judge; and
  • the Information and Data Protection Appeals Tribunal, which is established by the Data Protection Act (Chapter 586 of the Laws of Malta), and hears and decides appeals following a decision of the Information and Data Protection Commissioner relating to data protection law or freedom of information requests. One may also appeal the decision of the tribunal on a point of law before the Court of Appeal.

Timeframes for Getting to Trial

When it comes to proceedings before the Mal tese courts, there is no fixed timeframe within which a case must be scheduled for trial; the timing is entirely dependent on the practices of the presiding judge. However, in practice, after the filing of a court application, the first hear ing is typically set within eight weeks. This also applies to cases brought before specialised tri bunals.

An exception to this general position applies to special summary proceedings related to debt collection claims that are certain, liquid and due. In such cases, the hearing must be scheduled no earlier than 15 days and no later than 30 days after the respondent has been served with the sworn application.

1.3 Court Filings and Proceedings

All proceedings before the above-mentioned courts and tribunals are held in public, and all documents and records of the proceedings are accessible to the public. As an exception to this general rule, the relevant court or tribunal may order certain documents filed in the records of proceedings to be sealed, particularly where such documents contain confidential informa tion or may otherwise be prejudicial to the par ties to those proceedings. Any proceedings filed against or by the Financial Intelligence Analysis Unit (FIAU) involving money laundering cases are not public and are heard behind closed doors.

1.4 Legal Representation in Court

No person may exercise the profession of advocate in the Courts of Justice in Malta without the authority of the President of Malta, granted by warrant under the Public Seal of Malta. In order to obtain such a warrant, an individual must:

  • be a fit and proper person as recommended by the Committee for Advocates and Legal Procurators;
  • be of good conduct and morals;
  • be a citizen of Malta or of a member state of the European Union, or be otherwise permit ted to work in Malta under any law;
  • have obtained the academic degree in law from the University of Malta, or such other qualification at Master's level as the Minister may from time to time prescribe, after con sultation with the Senate of the University of Malta, or a comparable degree from such other competent authority in accordance with the principles of the mutual recognition of qualifications, after having read law in Malta or in a member state of the European Union (EU);
  • have, for a period of not less than one year, regularly attended the office of a practising advocate of the Bar of Malta and at the sit tings of the Superior Courts;
  • have full knowledge of the Maltese language, being the language of the courts; and
  • have been duly examined and approved by two judges.

Advocates so admitted to the Maltese Bar have rights of audience before all courts.

Legal procurators in possession of a warrant issued by the President of the Republic and under the Public Seal of Malta have rights of audience before the Courts of Magistrates (inferior jurisdiction) and special tribunals and boards.

Foreign legal professionals from other EU mem ber states wishing to practise in Malta may register with the Ministry for Justice, Equality and Governance, but will need to apply for a local warrant in order to practise in the Courts of Justice in Malta. To be eligible, the applicant should have practised law in Malta for at least three years, have experience of Maltese law, and must satisfy the remaining requirements.

Please click here to view the full article.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Mondaq uses cookies on this website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Learn More