12 April 2020

Health insurance or self-insurance?

Wynn Williams Lawyers


Wynn Williams is a renowned law firm in New Zealand, offering a full range of legal services with a team of skilled lawyers. Established in 1859, the firm is known for its expertise, straightforward advice, and strong client relationships. Recognized in prestigious legal directories, Wynn Williams is proud of its heritage and commitment to honest, experienced guidance for clients. Offices are located in Auckland, Christchurch, and Queenstown.
Private health insurance covers non-essential medical services, avoids waiting lists and allows your choice of doctor.
New Zealand Insurance
To print this article, all you need is to be registered or login on

The uptake of private health insurance in NZ is dropping. With our public health system and ACC meeting the cost of urgent medical care, and some resultant income loss, you might ask "is health insurance worth it?"

Self-insuring to save on insurance costs can be a valid option, if you have self-discipline and won't be tempted to spend your medical emergency fund on a tropical holiday or a new car.

For most people private health insurance is a good idea. Not only does it provide cover for non-essential medical treatment, more importantly, it enables you to avoid public waiting lists and to choose your doctor. When you are battling a serious or chronic medical condition, this can make all the difference.

If you choose private health insurance, there are some important considerations. Firstly, shop around and find the cover and cost that suits your needs. An insurance broker can help and there are also websites online that can compare health insurance policies and premiums for you.

Secondly, you will need to make full and frank disclosure of your medical history when taking out health insurance. Your health insurer can decline a claim if you fail to disclose material information, for example, a pre-existing medical condition, illness or injury, even if the eventual claim is completely unrelated to the initial non-disclosure. Smoking, mental health issues and chronic pain conditions are all red flag areas here.

Thirdly, the younger you are when taking out health insurance the better; as you will usually have less medical history to remember and disclose (and potentially for the insurer to exclude from cover).

Fourthly, if you can avoid it, it's best not to change health insurer. Changing insurer will trigger a whole new disclosure obligation and risk of you overlooking disclosing something.

Finally, if you do make a claim and your insurer has concerns about that claim, it may decide to investigate, which can include obtaining your medical records and/or reviewing your social media presence. Most material non-disclosures are identified this way.

Ultimately, while health insurance can meet your medical costs, your loss of income during a period of illness or incapacitation (not caused by an accident) can also be a significant burden. Income protection insurance, which can be bundled up with your health insurance, is worth considering too.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

See More Popular Content From

Mondaq uses cookies on this website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Learn More