United States: On The Heels Of Caronia: New York Appellate Court Rejects Medical Monitoring Costs Based On Mere Inhalation Of Toxic Substance

Last Updated: February 28 2014
Article by John J. DiChello,Jr.

Following the New York Court of Appeals's landmark decision last December in Caronia v. Philip Morris USA, Inc., No. 227, 2013 N.Y. LEXIS 3476 (N.Y. Dec. 17, 2013), refusing to recognize a stand-alone, equitable cause of action for medical monitoring but allowing medical monitoring as a remedy for an existing tort, the Third Department in Ivory v. IBM, No. 516276 (N.Y. App. Div. Feb. 20, 2014), ruled on February 20, 2014 that plaintiffs exposed to toxic substances may recover medical monitoring expenses as consequential damages for an underlying tort claim only if they come forward with proof of either property damage or personal injury. Significantly, the Third Department concluded that mere airborne exposure to or inhalation of a toxic substance does not satisfy the tort requirement of physical injury. The court's ruling in Ivory continues New York state courts' departure from the prior rulings of New York federal courts predicting (incorrectly) that New York would recognize an independent medical monitoring cause of action, as well as the laws of many other jurisdictions nationwide that permit stand-alone medical monitoring claims without a showing of property or physical harm.

In Ivory, a class of residents of the Village of Endicott in Broome County, New York filed several lawsuits against IBM for the contamination of groundwater with trichloroethylene ("TCE") and other solvents used by IBM in cleaning metal parts in degreasers and in manufacturing circuit boards, circuit cards, and other computer-related items at its Endicott facility between 1924 and 2002. The plaintiffs alleged that groundwater contaminated with TCE migrated from IBM's facility toward the plaintiffs' homes, contaminating soil and groundwater beneath their homes and exposing the plaintiffs to TCE through air emissions and vapor intrusion—in other words, by inhalation. The plaintiffs asserted claims for negligence, private nuisance, and trespass.

The claims of two families consisting of seven plaintiffs subsequently were severed for an initial bellwether trial.1 Notably, while two such plaintiffs, Thomas H. Ivory and Timothy Ivory, alleged that they had developed cancer from exposure to TCE, the remaining five plaintiffs did not have any physical manifestations of injury. None of the plaintiffs pleaded a stand-alone medical monitoring cause of action, which New York does not recognize anyway, but six of the plaintiffs sought medical monitoring expenses as consequential damages based on their tort claims.

In affirming the lower court's dismissal of the claims for medical monitoring damages except as to plaintiffs Timothy Ivory and Grace Odom, the Third Department in Ivory first avowed the New York Court of Appeals's ruling in Caronia that New York does not allow an independent cause of action for medical monitoring, and that medical monitoring expenses are recoverable as damages for an existing tort claim only if a party offers "evidence of present physical injury or damage to property." The Court of Appeals in Caronia based its ruling on public policy concerns associated with recognizing a new medical monitoring tort claim, namely, that dispensing with the typical tort requirement of physical injury would result in a flood of plaintiffs, many of whom may never contract a disease and are asymptomatic, seeking medical monitoring costs based on frivolous claims. Caronia, 2013 N.Y. LEXIS 3476, at *14-15. Not only would that overwhelm the courts, it would deplete the defendant's resources at the expense of those parties who may have actually suffered harm. Id. at *15. In addition, the Court of Appeals in Caronia was concerned that the judiciary lacked the technical and scientific expertise to administer a medical monitoring program. Id. at *16.

Because no plaintiff other than Timothy Ivory offered sufficient evidence of physical injuries caused by TCE,2 the Third Department in Ivory concluded only he could pursue medical monitoring as consequential damages for his negligence claim. Implicit in the court's ruling is that the inhalation of TCE, alone, is insufficient to establish the necessary physical injury to allow the plaintiffs to obtain medical monitoring relief for their tort claims. In other words, inhaling TCE, without any physical symptoms, is akin to no injury at all. Furthermore, the court held that only two plaintiffs, Grace Odom and Shawn Stevens, could seek medical monitoring damages consequential to their trespass claims because the remaining plaintiffs did not allege the necessary property damage—the contamination of soil beneath their homes.3 The court noted that the plaintiffs could not pursue medical monitoring in connection with their private nuisance cause of action because property damage is not an element of that claim and, in any event, the plaintiffs failed to allege property damage in their complaint. The remaining plaintiffs could not establish a valid underlying claim on which to base medical monitoring damages.

With respect to the plaintiffs' other claims, the Third Department reversed the lower court's denial of IBM's motion for summary judgment on the trespass claim based on vapor intrusion, air emissions, and groundwater contamination. The court reasoned that intangible intrusions such as air emissions and vapor intrusion are insufficient to establish a trespass claim (a private nuisance claim, which depends on the interference with use and enjoyment of property, may be grounded on air emissions and vapor intrusion). The court added that plaintiffs Thomas H. Ivory, Grace Odom, and Shawn Stevens could not assert a trespass claim based on groundwater contamination because groundwater does not belong to owners of real property; it is a natural resource entrusted to the state for its citizens. The court also affirmed the lower court's dismissal of the private nuisance claim asserted by plaintiff James Odom for lack of standing because he did not have legal ownership of the home at which he allegedly was exposed to TCE. Under New York law, only occupants of a home with an ownership or possessory interest may maintain a claim for private nuisance. Lastly, the court affirmed the lower court's denial of IBM's motion for summary judgment on the negligence claims of plaintiff Thomas H. Ivory and Timothy Ivory due to the existence of factual issues.

While the Third Department in Ivory allowed certain plaintiffs to proceed to trial on their claims against IBM, the court's decision, as a whole, should be considered a victory for those defending against and/or concerned about toxic tort claims in a New York forum. Not only did the Third Department reaffirm the Court of Appeals's ruling in Caronia barring medical monitoring as an independent cause of action and as a remedy absent a cognizable personal injury or property damage claim, the Third Department's decision effectively precludes the recovery of medical monitoring damages for tort claims solely based on inhalation of a hazardous substance. Under the court's ruling, inhaling a hazardous substance—without any actual, concrete physical symptom—does not constitute a discernible physical injury to support medical monitoring relief. This reinforces the public policy rationale underlying the decision in Caronia that allowing an asymptomatic plaintiff who may never contract a disease to recover medical monitoring expenses would divert money away from those who have actually sustained injuries and cause a wave of frivolous lawsuits based on speculation. The plaintiffs in Ivory, of course, are not left empty-handed, since the New York Department of Environmental Conservation and Department of Health required IBM to offer ventilation systems to owners of homes in which TCE was present as part of IBM's remediation efforts. If the New York Court of Appeals upholds this decision on appeal, defendants in toxic tort cases arising under New York law will have an additional significant safeguard against attenuated tort claims for medical monitoring costs.

Footnotes

1. The lower court originally severed eight plaintiffs, but one of those plaintiffs passed away and his claims were discontinued.

2. Plaintiff Thomas H. Ivory also presented proof of a physical injury, but he did not seek medical monitoring damages.

3. Plaintiff Shawn Stevens, however, waived her right to pursue medical monitoring costs as consequential damages associated with the trespass claim alleging property damage because she voluntarily discontinued her property damage claims.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

To print this article, all you need is to be registered on Mondaq.com.

Click to Login as an existing user or Register so you can print this article.

Authors
John J. DiChello,Jr.
 
In association with
Related Video
Up-coming Events Search
Tools
Print
Font Size:
Translation
Channels
Mondaq on Twitter
 
Register for Access and our Free Biweekly Alert for
This service is completely free. Access 250,000 archived articles from 100+ countries and get a personalised email twice a week covering developments (and yes, our lawyers like to think you’ve read our Disclaimer).
 
Email Address
Company Name
Password
Confirm Password
Position
Mondaq Topics -- Select your Interests
 Accounting
 Anti-trust
 Commercial
 Compliance
 Consumer
 Criminal
 Employment
 Energy
 Environment
 Family
 Finance
 Government
 Healthcare
 Immigration
 Insolvency
 Insurance
 International
 IP
 Law Performance
 Law Practice
 Litigation
 Media & IT
 Privacy
 Real Estate
 Strategy
 Tax
 Technology
 Transport
 Wealth Mgt
Regions
Africa
Asia
Asia Pacific
Australasia
Canada
Caribbean
Europe
European Union
Latin America
Middle East
U.K.
United States
Worldwide Updates
Check to state you have read and
agree to our Terms and Conditions

Terms & Conditions and Privacy Statement

Mondaq.com (the Website) is owned and managed by Mondaq Ltd and as a user you are granted a non-exclusive, revocable license to access the Website under its terms and conditions of use. Your use of the Website constitutes your agreement to the following terms and conditions of use. Mondaq Ltd may terminate your use of the Website if you are in breach of these terms and conditions or if Mondaq Ltd decides to terminate your license of use for whatever reason.

Use of www.mondaq.com

You may use the Website but are required to register as a user if you wish to read the full text of the content and articles available (the Content). You may not modify, publish, transmit, transfer or sell, reproduce, create derivative works from, distribute, perform, link, display, or in any way exploit any of the Content, in whole or in part, except as expressly permitted in these terms & conditions or with the prior written consent of Mondaq Ltd. You may not use electronic or other means to extract details or information about Mondaq.com’s content, users or contributors in order to offer them any services or products which compete directly or indirectly with Mondaq Ltd’s services and products.

Disclaimer

Mondaq Ltd and/or its respective suppliers make no representations about the suitability of the information contained in the documents and related graphics published on this server for any purpose. All such documents and related graphics are provided "as is" without warranty of any kind. Mondaq Ltd and/or its respective suppliers hereby disclaim all warranties and conditions with regard to this information, including all implied warranties and conditions of merchantability, fitness for a particular purpose, title and non-infringement. In no event shall Mondaq Ltd and/or its respective suppliers be liable for any special, indirect or consequential damages or any damages whatsoever resulting from loss of use, data or profits, whether in an action of contract, negligence or other tortious action, arising out of or in connection with the use or performance of information available from this server.

The documents and related graphics published on this server could include technical inaccuracies or typographical errors. Changes are periodically added to the information herein. Mondaq Ltd and/or its respective suppliers may make improvements and/or changes in the product(s) and/or the program(s) described herein at any time.

Registration

Mondaq Ltd requires you to register and provide information that personally identifies you, including what sort of information you are interested in, for three primary purposes:

  • To allow you to personalize the Mondaq websites you are visiting.
  • To enable features such as password reminder, newsletter alerts, email a colleague, and linking from Mondaq (and its affiliate sites) to your website.
  • To produce demographic feedback for our information providers who provide information free for your use.

Mondaq (and its affiliate sites) do not sell or provide your details to third parties other than information providers. The reason we provide our information providers with this information is so that they can measure the response their articles are receiving and provide you with information about their products and services.

If you do not want us to provide your name and email address you may opt out by clicking here .

If you do not wish to receive any future announcements of products and services offered by Mondaq by clicking here .

Information Collection and Use

We require site users to register with Mondaq (and its affiliate sites) to view the free information on the site. We also collect information from our users at several different points on the websites: this is so that we can customise the sites according to individual usage, provide 'session-aware' functionality, and ensure that content is acquired and developed appropriately. This gives us an overall picture of our user profiles, which in turn shows to our Editorial Contributors the type of person they are reaching by posting articles on Mondaq (and its affiliate sites) – meaning more free content for registered users.

We are only able to provide the material on the Mondaq (and its affiliate sites) site free to site visitors because we can pass on information about the pages that users are viewing and the personal information users provide to us (e.g. email addresses) to reputable contributing firms such as law firms who author those pages. We do not sell or rent information to anyone else other than the authors of those pages, who may change from time to time. Should you wish us not to disclose your details to any of these parties, please tick the box above or tick the box marked "Opt out of Registration Information Disclosure" on the Your Profile page. We and our author organisations may only contact you via email or other means if you allow us to do so. Users can opt out of contact when they register on the site, or send an email to unsubscribe@mondaq.com with “no disclosure” in the subject heading

Mondaq News Alerts

In order to receive Mondaq News Alerts, users have to complete a separate registration form. This is a personalised service where users choose regions and topics of interest and we send it only to those users who have requested it. Users can stop receiving these Alerts by going to the Mondaq News Alerts page and deselecting all interest areas. In the same way users can amend their personal preferences to add or remove subject areas.

Cookies

A cookie is a small text file written to a user’s hard drive that contains an identifying user number. The cookies do not contain any personal information about users. We use the cookie so users do not have to log in every time they use the service and the cookie will automatically expire if you do not visit the Mondaq website (or its affiliate sites) for 12 months. We also use the cookie to personalise a user's experience of the site (for example to show information specific to a user's region). As the Mondaq sites are fully personalised and cookies are essential to its core technology the site will function unpredictably with browsers that do not support cookies - or where cookies are disabled (in these circumstances we advise you to attempt to locate the information you require elsewhere on the web). However if you are concerned about the presence of a Mondaq cookie on your machine you can also choose to expire the cookie immediately (remove it) by selecting the 'Log Off' menu option as the last thing you do when you use the site.

Some of our business partners may use cookies on our site (for example, advertisers). However, we have no access to or control over these cookies and we are not aware of any at present that do so.

Log Files

We use IP addresses to analyse trends, administer the site, track movement, and gather broad demographic information for aggregate use. IP addresses are not linked to personally identifiable information.

Links

This web site contains links to other sites. Please be aware that Mondaq (or its affiliate sites) are not responsible for the privacy practices of such other sites. We encourage our users to be aware when they leave our site and to read the privacy statements of these third party sites. This privacy statement applies solely to information collected by this Web site.

Surveys & Contests

From time-to-time our site requests information from users via surveys or contests. Participation in these surveys or contests is completely voluntary and the user therefore has a choice whether or not to disclose any information requested. Information requested may include contact information (such as name and delivery address), and demographic information (such as postcode, age level). Contact information will be used to notify the winners and award prizes. Survey information will be used for purposes of monitoring or improving the functionality of the site.

Mail-A-Friend

If a user elects to use our referral service for informing a friend about our site, we ask them for the friend’s name and email address. Mondaq stores this information and may contact the friend to invite them to register with Mondaq, but they will not be contacted more than once. The friend may contact Mondaq to request the removal of this information from our database.

Emails

From time to time Mondaq may send you emails promoting Mondaq services including new services. You may opt out of receiving such emails by clicking below.

*** If you do not wish to receive any future announcements of services offered by Mondaq you may opt out by clicking here .

Security

This website takes every reasonable precaution to protect our users’ information. When users submit sensitive information via the website, your information is protected using firewalls and other security technology. If you have any questions about the security at our website, you can send an email to webmaster@mondaq.com.

Correcting/Updating Personal Information

If a user’s personally identifiable information changes (such as postcode), or if a user no longer desires our service, we will endeavour to provide a way to correct, update or remove that user’s personal data provided to us. This can usually be done at the “Your Profile” page or by sending an email to EditorialAdvisor@mondaq.com.

Notification of Changes

If we decide to change our Terms & Conditions or Privacy Policy, we will post those changes on our site so our users are always aware of what information we collect, how we use it, and under what circumstances, if any, we disclose it. If at any point we decide to use personally identifiable information in a manner different from that stated at the time it was collected, we will notify users by way of an email. Users will have a choice as to whether or not we use their information in this different manner. We will use information in accordance with the privacy policy under which the information was collected.

How to contact Mondaq

You can contact us with comments or queries at enquiries@mondaq.com.

If for some reason you believe Mondaq Ltd. has not adhered to these principles, please notify us by e-mail at problems@mondaq.com and we will use commercially reasonable efforts to determine and correct the problem promptly.