ARTICLE
3 February 2014

You Can’t Fire Me! I’m Disabled!

FL
Foley & Lardner

Contributor

Foley & Lardner LLP looks beyond the law to focus on the constantly evolving demands facing our clients and their industries. With over 1,100 lawyers in 24 offices across the United States, Mexico, Europe and Asia, Foley approaches client service by first understanding our clients’ priorities, objectives and challenges. We work hard to understand our clients’ issues and forge long-term relationships with them to help achieve successful outcomes and solve their legal issues through practical business advice and cutting-edge legal insight. Our clients view us as trusted business advisors because we understand that great legal service is only valuable if it is relevant, practical and beneficial to their businesses.
For years, courts have often ruled that employees cannot use last-minute declarations of disabilities to protect themselves from the potential consequences of their actions or avoid getting fired.
United States Employment and HR

For years, courts have often ruled that employees cannot use last-minute declarations of disabilities to protect themselves from the potential consequences of their actions or avoid getting fired. But a recent decision suggests that employers should still take such statements seriously.

Consider this: A night-shift employee repeatedly fell asleep at work. The employer gave her repeated warnings, leading up to a suspension. Despite the discipline, she continued to sleep on the job. As a result, her manager suspended her indefinitely pending further investigation and told her that she could be terminated. A day later, the Human Resources Manager recommended that the employee be terminated, and twelve days after the recommendation, the employer followed through and informed the employee of the termination.

So far, this sounds like a run-of-the-mill performance termination. But here comes the wrinkle: After the employee kept falling asleep, and after the employer issued the final suspension and told her about possible termination, and after the HR manager recommended termination, the employee told the employer that she may have had a disability that was keeping her from staying awake. After receiving this notice, the employer went ahead with the termination.

It goes without saying that an employer cannot be held liable for disability discrimination if it is not aware of the disability. Here, the employer argued that it had no idea about the employee's disability: (1) when the employee kept falling asleep on the job; (2) when it issued the discipline; and (3) when the HR manager recommended the termination. According to the employer then, it could not have been discriminating on the basis of the employee's disability because it did not know about it at the time that it considered whether to fire her.

Not so fast, according to the Seventh Circuit Court of Appeals. A termination does not occur, according to the Court, until:

  1. The employer makes a "final, ultimate, non-tentative" decision; and
  2. The employee receives "unequivocal notice" of the decision. Because the employer learned about the disability before making the final decision, and before telling the employee, the court ruled that her ADA discrimination claim could go forward.

So what does this all mean? According to the ruling, even if an employer decides to terminate an employee for performance issues without any knowledge of a disability but then learns about the disability before telling the employee, the employer may need to reevaluate its decision. At the very least, the decision suggests that employers must at least consider whether the alleged disability is linked to the performance issues. Otherwise, the employer faces the risk of an ADA claim and the possibility of a sympathetic plaintiff.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Mondaq uses cookies on this website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Learn More