With military reservists being "called up" due to the tragic events of September 11th, 2001, many employers are beginning to encounter questions concerning military leave. Under a federal law known as the Uniformed Services Employment and Reemployment Rights Act of 1994, 38 USC section 4301, et seq. ("USERRA"), employers:

1. May not discriminate against employees with military service obligations;

2. Must provide employees with leave and reinstatement rights; and

3. Must continue (or allow the employee to continue) certain benefits.

Florida law supplements the Federal law in several respects, namely, in compensation and leave of absence protections for employees who work for public employers.

Federal Law

Prohibitions

USERRA prohibits discrimination against employees or prospective employees in hiring, retention, promotion or any employment benefit because of past, present or future application for, or membership in, the uniformed service. In practice, this means that employers should watch for critical or derogatory comments regarding an employee's military service or time off needed to train for that service. In addition, employment applications and interviewing techniques should be free from questions relating to potential military service obligations that could have an adverse impact on those in the uniformed services.

Who Is Covered

USERRA applies to all employers, both public and private, regardless of their size.

USERRA applies to all types of military "uniformed services." This includes the Armed Forces (Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines), the Army National Guard, the Air National Guard, the Coast Guard, the commissioned corps of the Public Health Service, and any other category of persons designated by the President in the case of a war or emergency.

To be covered by USERRA, an employee must meet five conditions:

  1. Be employed or have applied for employment with a civilian employer
  2. Provide notice, either verbally or in writing, to the employer prior to leaving the job for military duty, unless exigencies of military service precluded the opportunity to give such notice
  3. Not have exceeded the 5-year cumulative service standard (i.e., absence of more than five years due to Reserve service while working for one employer)
  4. Not have been released from the period of service for which s/he gave notice under:
    1. Other than honorable conditions; or
    2. Bad conduct discharge; or
    3. Dishonorable discharge
  5. And, report back to the employer in a timely manner or submit a timely application for employment following the release from the period of service for which s/he gave notice.

Reporting Back

An employee must report back to the civilian job within a specified period of time following the end of the period of military service.

1. Service up to 30 consecutive days:

Employee must report back for the first regularly scheduled work period on the first full calendar day following the completion of service and safe transportation home, plus an 8 hour period of time to rest once at home.

2. Service of 31 – 180 days:

Employee must submit a written or verbal application for reemployment to the employer not later than 14 calendar days following the completion of service.

3. Service over 180 days:

Employee has 90 days following the completion of service to submit his/her application for reemployment.

These timelines may be extended for up to two years for any veteran who has been hospitalized or who is convalescing because of a disability incurred or aggravated during military service, and employers must make reasonable accommodation for any impairment (presumably under the federal and state disability laws).

The employer may require a returning employee to provide documentation to establish that the application was timely, that the employee had not exceeded the military service limitations, and that entitlement to benefits under USERRA has not been terminated. Where such documentation does not exist or is not readily available, employers still must reemploy the reservist/veteran until that documentation becomes available.

Any person absent from employment for more than 30 days may be required to provide documentation before the employer will be required to treat the person as not having incurred a break in service for pension purposes.

Reemployment Rights

Except with respect to a veteran, whose disability occurred in or was aggravated by military service, the position to which a veteran is reinstated is determined by priority, based on the length of military service. The rules are as follows:

1. Prompt reinstatement, which is dependent on individual circumstances.

2. Service of 1 to 90 Days:

The employer must reinstate the veteran in the job s/he would have held had s/he remained continuously employed (possibly a promoted position), so long as the veteran is qualified for the job or can become qualified after reasonable efforts by the employer, or if the veteran cannot become qualified, the employer must reinstate the veteran in the job s/he held on the date of the commencement of the military service.

3. Service of 91 or More Days:

The employer must reinstate the veteran in the job s/he would have held absent military leave, or to a job with similar seniority, status and pay, as long as s/he is qualified to perform that job.

Notes:

A veteran with a service-connected disability who cannot be reasonably accommodated in the job to which s/he would otherwise have been entitled, may be placed in another equivalent position that s/he is qualified to perform.

Veterans who are not qualified for the job they would otherwise have received for reasons other than disability may be placed in a lower position with less pay, but with full seniority. (38 USC section 4313).

The employer must make "reasonable efforts" to retrain the returning employee to qualify for the position required to be offered to the employee; if retraining isn’t feasible, then the employer may place the employee into a position of lesser pay and status.

"Qualified" means "having the ability to perform the essential tasks of the position" (38 USC section 4304(9)).

There is a special protection against discharge. An employer may not discharge a reinstated veteran except for cause for:

  1. 180 days if the absence was from 31 to 180 days;
  2. One year if the absence was greater than 181 days.

Note: the statute is silent as to a special treatment period for duty of less than 31 days, but a suspect termination would create a presumption of discriminatory treatment by the employer.

Pay And Benefites During Leave

Leave under USERRA is unpaid, except that a person may elect to use any vacation, annual or similar accrued paid leave. Employers may not require employees to use accrued paid leave during military leave (38 USC section 4316). The employee is entitled to:

  1. Accrued seniority, and other benefits determined by seniority that s/he had at the commencement of the service. The employee also is entitled to any additional seniority and benefits s/he would have attained, with reasonable certainty, had s/he remained continuously employed.
  2. Any non-seniority benefits offered by the employer to employees on various types of furlough or leave of absence must also be offered to the service member.
  3. The employer must continue to make the employer contributions to a pension or profit sharing plan, as if the employee was still actively employed. Further, a reinstated employee may not be treated as having had a "break in service" for pension purposes because of military service, and the period of military service must be counted as employment for purposes of vesting schedules and accrual of pension benefits.
  4. The employee has the right to elect to continue to be covered by the employer-provided group health insurance for up to 18 months at the employee's expense under COBRA (except that the employer must continue to pay its usual share of the premium for leaves lasting up to 31 days). Further, no coverage exclusion or waiting period may be imposed on a reinstated employee (or on any covered dependent) because of his/her absence for military service (38 USC section 4317).

Veterans Benefits And Health Care Improvement Act Of 2000

On a related note, a new federal law also allows military reservists to take time off from work to serve as honor guards at veterans' funerals (Veterans Benefits and Health Care Improvement Act of 2000, Public Law 106-419). The law took effect April 30, 2001.

FLORIDA LAW

Prohibitions

  • National Guard:

  • Public and private employers are prohibited from discharging, reprimanding, or penalizing in any way an employee who is called to active duty by the National Guard. Fla. Stat. §250.482.

All officials of the state, counties, municipalities or political subdivisions of the state, including district school and community college officers, which officials are also officers or enlisted personnel in the National Guard or a Reserve Component of the United States Armed Forces may be granted leave of absence from their respective offices and duties to perform active military service, the first 30 days of any such leave shall be with full pay. Fla. Stat. §§ 115.09 and 250.48.

  • Armed Forces

Public and private employer are also prohibited from discriminating against individuals in hiring, retaining, or promoting an individual, or denying an individual any advantages of employment, because of the individual’s obligations as a member of a Reserve Component of the Armed Forces, which includes the Army, Navy, Air Force, Marines, U.S. Coast Guard, and the Public Health Service. Fla. Stat. §250.481.

During leave of absence the employee is entitled to preserve all seniority rights, efficiency ratings, promotional status and retirement privileges. Fla. Stat. §§115.12 and 115.14.

Notes:

1 Brief and nonrecurring jobs do not qualify an individual as "employed."

2 The statute is silent on an express time period.

Allen, Norton & Blue, P.A. publishes this article as general information only. It is not intended and may not be considered as legal advice.