ARTICLE
26 October 2014

Making someone redundant whilst on parental leave – is it automatically grounds for a discrimination claim?

CG
Coleman Greig Lawyers

Contributor

Coleman Greig is a leading law firm in Sydney, focusing on empowering clients through legal services and value-adding initiatives. With over 95 years of experience, we cater to a wide range of clients from individuals to multinational enterprises. Our flexible work environment and commitment to innovation ensure the best service for our clients. We integrate with the community and strive for excellence in all aspects of our work.
An employee's absence can lead to the conclusion that that employee's position is not in fact required.
Australia Employment and HR

No!

A recent decision has highlighted that an employee's absence (whether on parental leave or some other form of leave) can, in the right circumstances, lead to the conclusion that that employee's position is not in fact required.

In the relevant case a female employee alleged that she was "targeted" by management as a consequence of her pregnancy, the birth of her child and her parental leave, and that her redundancy was "manufactured" rather than being the legitimate outcome of her employer restructuring its operations.

In that case the court concluded that the employer's decision to make the employee redundant legitimately came about due to her absence from work, because:

  • it enabled "alternative arrangements to be tested and found satisfactory"; and
  • it created the circumstances in which the employer concluded it no longer needed the employee's position because while she was on leave her duties were easily absorbed by other employees.

See Poppy v Service to Youth Council Incorporated [2014] FCA 656 (20 June 2014) for more information.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Mondaq uses cookies on this website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Learn More