A couple of weeks ago the G20 group of countries signed off on
an OECD Action Plan to tackle tax base erosion and multinational
profit shifting. Dr Niv Tadmore sets out what this will mean for
Base erosion and multinational profit shifting: Where to
Dr Niv Tadmore, Partner, Clayton Utz
A couple of weeks ago the G20 group of countries signed
off on an OECD Action Plan to tackle tax base erosion and
multinational profit shifting. Shortly after the G20's
announcement, the Australian Government issued a report endorsing
the Action Plan. What is the Action Plan seeking to
Dr Niv Tadmore
The Action Plan is seeking to address two tax issues: profit
shifting and base erosion. If you picture a lake, and lots of
fishing boats on that lake casting the nets, each fishing boat
would represent a government and each net would represent a tax
Profit shifting is about the effectiveness of the nets. Are they
damaged? Are there too many holes? Are the holes too big? Or do we
have a situation where too many fish can escape the net?
Base erosion is a slightly different question. It is about the
size of the net. Are the nets too small? Base erosion goes back to
the genesis of international tax. Our current rules were designed
almost 100 years ago in an era where you needed tangible things
that you could feel and touch in order to make profits. Today we
live in a different era and business models, economic values and
profits do not always depend on physical presence, but the tax laws
have not caught up with those developments. So there is a
disconnect between the tax design and the business realities.
So what OECD is trying to do within the next two years is to
seek to repair the nets and probably make them bigger.
In the past we have seen big ticket tax reform agendas
which were not carried through. Will it be different this time
Dr Niv Tadmore
I think it will be different. It is almost a perfect storm. At
the political level, the G20 has endorsed that action plan and the
political pressure is critical to any global corporation. In
Australia, the Government has put together a special reference
group that has worked Treasury and in those meetings I got a very
strong sense that the Government is strongly committed to those
issues and to address those issues, and of course the OECD action
And in Australia what we also have is a new, an upgraded tax
system mainly in the areas of transfer pricing and Part IVA so the
ATO has a strong set of tools to deal with these issues. And the
ATO itself has received special funding and established a special
task force to deal with these issues. So we almost have a perfect
alignment of the planets in terms of global political consensus and
a strong commitment, a robust and comprehensive tax system and a
What will this mean in practice?
Dr Niv Tadmore
Australia already has a sophisticated and robust tax system so I
don't think that we'll see major game changes in Australia,
but I think that we will see three major developments.
The first one will be in the area of transfer pricing and that
will be a push that will come from the OECD which has said it is
going to look intangibles and financial transactions.
Our laws incorporate the OECD guidelines by reference, so
whatever the OECD may do with its guidelines will have a direct
impact in Australia.
The second area is a much more sophisticated corporation
information sharing arrangement between countries. That means that
the ATO will have much more information to look at when it reviews
the affairs of an Australian taxpayer or subsidiary of a foreign
taxpayer in Australia.
And the third area will be I think will relate to disclosure. I
believe that what the OECD is trying to do in Australia is to ask
companies to disclose much more about their tax affairs when they
lodge their returns and when they go for an ATO review.
So if you want to wrap it all up, I don't think that we will
see any huge storms on that lake, but there'll be waves,
there'll be some wind, and some fog, so we're going to go
into an area of uncertainty for a couple of years and then things I
believe will clear up.
Clayton Utz communications are intended to provide
commentary and general information. They should not be relied upon
as legal advice. Formal legal advice should be sought in particular
transactions or on matters of interest arising from this bulletin.
Persons listed may not be admitted in all states and
To print this article, all you need is to be registered on Mondaq.com.
Click to Login as an existing user or Register so you can print this article.
The income tax treatment of any property lease incentive will vary, depending on the nature of the inducement provided.
Some comments from our readers… “The articles are extremely timely and highly applicable” “I often find critical information not available elsewhere” “As in-house counsel, Mondaq’s service is of great value”
Register for Access and our Free Biweekly Alert for
This service is completely free. Access 250,000 archived articles from 100+ countries and get a personalised email twice a week covering developments (and yes, our lawyers like to think you’ve read our Disclaimer).