HSBC UK Bank plc, HSBC Bank plc, and Marks and Spencer Financial Services plc (HSBC) have been fined £6,280,100 by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). This penalty stems from failures in HSBC's treatment of customers experiencing financial difficulties or arrears between June 2017 and October 2018.
During the specified period, HSBC reportedly did not adequately consider customers' individual circumstances when they missed payments. This lapse led to inadequate affordability assessments when establishing arrangements to address arrears. In some instances, the bank took disproportionate actions against customers falling behind on payments, potentially exacerbating their financial challenges. This allegedly left 1.5 million people at risk of financial harm.
The FCA's investigation attributed these failures to deficiencies in HSBC's policies, procedures, and staff training, coupled with inadequate mechanisms to detect and rectify instances of unfair customer treatment. Despite these shortcomings, HSBC took proactive steps in 2018 by self-identifying the issues and promptly notifying the FCA.
HSBC's response included a substantial £94 million investment to rectify the identified issues comprehensively. Moreover, the bank disbursed £185 million in redress payments to over 1.5 million affected customers. This remediation and redress program played a pivotal role in the FCA's decision-making process, resulting in a 30% reduction in the financial penalty imposed on HSBC.
The FCA, emphasised the critical importance of fair treatment for customers in financial difficulty. The imposed fine serves as a reminder to all lenders of the imperative to understand and consider customers' financial circumstances judiciously.
Looking Ahead
As HSBC continues to enhance its customer handling processes, this incident highlights broader industry lessons on the necessity of robust policies, rigorous training, and vigilant oversight in financial institutions. Customers are encouraged to remain informed about their rights and engage proactively with lenders to ensure fair treatment, especially during challenging financial periods.
The FCA's enforcement action against HSBC shows its commitment to upholding standards of fairness and integrity in the financial services sector, reinforcing trust and accountability between lenders and consumers.
The FCA's enforcement action emphasises the importance of lenders treating customers in financial difficulty with fairness and consideration. Mortgage holders can expect heightened scrutiny and expectations from their lenders regarding affordability assessments and handling of arrears.
Following HSBC's shortcomings, mortgage lenders across the industry may review their own policies, procedures, and staff training to ensure they meet regulatory standards. This could lead to refinements in how lenders engage with customers experiencing financial challenges, potentially improving overall customer service.
HSBC's significant investment in identifying and rectifying issues, along with the substantial redress payments made to affected customers, sets a precedent for other lenders. Mortgage holders who believe they have been unfairly treated or faced undue financial hardship may be more inclined to seek redress or assistance from their lenders.
Originally published July 8, 2024.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
