ARTICLE
25 September 2013

Recital Creates An Estoppel

CR
Charles Russell Speechlys LLP

Contributor

We are an international law firm with a focus on private capital, at the intersection of personal, family and business. We have a broad range of skills and collective legal expertise and experience with an international outlook across the full spectrum of business and personal needs. Our firm is headquartered in London with offices across the UK, Europe, Asia and the Middle East. Whether your business operates in a single country or across borders, we’ll put together your perfect team – pulling from our sector and geographical expertise and our partnerships with the best law firms across the world covering 200 legal jurisdictions.

A discussion on the judicial findings in Prime Sight Limited v Lavarello (Official Trustee) [2013] UK PC 22.
United Kingdom Corporate/Commercial Law

Prime Sight Limited v Lavarello (Official Trustee) [2013] UK PC 22

Clause 1 of a deed of assignment recited that : "In consideration of the sum of £499,950 now paid by the Assignee to the Assignor (receipt and payment of which the Assignor hereby acknowledges), the Assignor as beneficial owner hereby assigns...". It was common ground that no payment had in fact been made and the question arose as to whether the assignor could claim the agreed purchase price in light of the "recital". It was not known why consideration was stated but not paid; one witness said that it was done for tax reasons.

The Privy Council held that the assignor was estopped by the terms of the deed from asserting that the purchase price had not been paid. If a recital in a deed amounted to a mutual agreement to treat it as true, and there were no vitiating factors such as illegality or misrepresentation, the contract should be enforced. There was nothing inherently contrary to public policy if parties agreed to contract on the basis that certain facts were to be treated or established for the purposes of their transaction, although they knew the facts to be otherwise. Here, there was no question of mistake or misrepresentation.

Comment

Be careful that recitals are accurate.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

Mondaq uses cookies on this website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Learn More