"People have only as much liberty as they have the intelligence to want and the courage to take." ―
Emma Goldman
1. INTRODUCTION
With the success of the initial phase of the Startup India Initiative1 and the emergence of tech focused startups, the attention of the Government has shifted to strengthen India's deep tech startup ecosystem. The Office of the Principal Scientific Adviser along with the National Deep Tech Startup Policy Consortium,2 on July 31, 2023, released the Draft National Deep Tech Startup Policy3 ("NDTS Policy") for public feedback. It is a comprehensive framework to address the challenges faced by deep tech startups and aims to enhance the deep tech ecosystem through policy interventions.
The NDTS Policy is anchored on four prominent pillars: (a) ensuring the security of India's economic future, (b) progress towards a knowledge-driven economy, (c) strengthening national capability through the Atmanirbhar Bharat imperative, and (d) encouraging ethical innovation. Aligned with India's deep tech vision, the NDTS Policy emphasises on positive impact of deep tech in critical areas such as food security, healthcare, and sustainability, while also focusing on diversity, inclusion, and skilled workforce development.
The support from the Government towards the development of deep tech start-ups can be seen through initiatives such as the recent proposal to set up an INR 1 trillion corpus with fifty-year interest free loan, to fund certain sunrise domains.4
2. WHAT IS A DEEP-TECH STARTUP?
The NDTS Policy does not provide an exhaustive definition of a deep tech startup and only attempts to lay down certain attributes of the same. The NDTS Policy recognises the evolving nature of deep tech startups in India and tries to address the need for development in this area by identifying the key attributes of their business, such as the maturity level of emerging technologies, applicability in different sectors, geographical boundaries, time frame, etc.
While the NDTS Policy recognises the lack of a standard definition, it attempts to lay down certain parameters or features that aid in identifying a deep tech startup. These include:
- An early-stage technology based on scientific or engineering advancements, which are yet to be developed for any commercial applications.
- Typically produces a solution along an unexplored pathway based on new knowledge within a scientific or engineering discipline or by combining knowledge from multiple disciplines.
- Carries a large technical or scientific uncertainty and hence presents a large opportunity or risk depending upon whether it succeeds.
- Is characterised by extended development timelines and requires high capital intensity.
- Typically, where the investment in Research & Development ("R&D") is high and academic research is advanced, deep tech startups tend to have a wider application, longer gestation period and sustain through higher financial investments.
- The technology/product should have a disruptive, problem-solving potential for the most pressing issues faced by India.5
3. KEY THEMATIC AREAS FOR NURTURING INDIA'S DEEP TECH STARTUP ECOSYSTEM
According to the Startup India's database6 , there are approximately 10,300 startups recognised by the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT) that are classified across sub-sectors within the larger deep tech space. These are entities that are typically engaged in activities such as artificial intelligence (including Natural Language Processing (NLP) and Machine Learning (ML)), internet of things, security solutions, analytics (including big data, data science), robotics, augmented and virtual reality, nanotechnology, etc.
There has been a notable rise in the number of mergers and acquisitions and substantial funding for Indian deep tech startups since the last decade, which has demonstrated the appeal of deep tech startups for investors and their considerable potential. New businesses have entered the deep tech startup landscape in India, thereby strengthening the entrepreneurial culture in the field of advanced science and new-age technology.
With nine thematic priorities being the central focus of the NDTS Policy, it aims to engage a diverse range of stakeholders to create a conducive environment for innovation, entrepreneurship, and technological advancement. In this article, we have tried to summarise the key principles underlying the nine themes, for which the Government believes policy intervention is specifically required.
3.1. Nurturing Research, Development & Innovation
One of the priorities of the NDTS Policy is to increase the gross expenditure on R&D, with development of suitable fund allocation opportunities from both public and private sources. The impact of focussed investments into R&D activities and curiosity driven scientific research is significant for development of know-how, scientific breakthroughs and even ensuring growth and utilisation of skilled workforce. To address these issues, the NDTS Policy proposes formation of the "Centre for Deep Tech Translation" for facilitating seamless partnership, establishing collaborative platforms, and providing guidelines for strengthening translation and commercialisation.
3.2. Fortified IP Regime
The NDTS Policy recognises that effective IP protection is critical for commercialisation and global competitiveness of Indian deep tech startups. The NDTS Policy addresses specific challenges and offers relevant solutions such as establishing a single window platform for, (a) creation of a unified IP framework; (b) providing guidelines for developing design IPs; (c) implementing robust cybersecurity measures; (d) monitoring access and use of confidential information; and (e) streamlining the patent application process.
The NDTS Policy also recommends participation in global IP related conventions and integrating provisions in free trade agreements for protection of IP created by Indian deep tech startups. Further, in case where technologies are developed for strategic sectors relying on Government funding, the NDTS Policy suggests granting Government Purpose Rights (GPR) such as non-exclusive, nontransferable licenses for internal use or manufacturing and even recommend a license fee to be paid by the Government for use of such GPRs. It also recommends enabling 'March-In' rights in cases concerning national security, including seeking a prior governmental approval where the management and control of the Indian company shifts to a foreign entity.
3.3. Fuelling Growth by Facilitating Funding
Access to funding for deep tech startups is particularly necessary due to their high capital requirements and long gestation periods for determining market fit. Currently, to secure funding, startups are tapping into diverse sources ranging from government grants, seed funding programs, accelerator programs, to Venture Capitalists, angel investors, or private equity firms in exchange for equity ownership.
The "Valley of Death" is a critical phase in a startup's lifecycle where it requires substantial funding to progress further but faces the risk of failure due to lack of resources or revenue. Startups often struggle with funding limitations during this period, hindering crucial activities like technology development and commercialisation. Overcoming the Valley of Death is essential, and relatively challenging for deep tech startups to sustain growth and successfully bring their innovations to the market. By addressing funding challenges and provision of targeted policy support, startups can navigate this phase and emerge stronger on the other side. Accordingly, the NDTS Policy proposes certain funding related initiatives such as:
- Creation of a centralised single window platform capturing the lifecycle of government grants (including disbursal, tracking and feedback) to streamline financing and enhance transparency. The technical feasibility of a deep tech startup shall be assessed by a committee of experts from industry, academia, and R&D. Participation of technical experts from higher education institutes shall be incentivised through compensation and factoring it in their appraisal evaluation.
- CSR funding for long term patent grants for select science-based research institutions.
- Dedicated deep tech capital guidance fund to be established for early-stage startups, where government, private Limited Partners (LPs) and foreign investors commit to a new fund in the form of a Fund of Funds (FoF), with the sub funds focusing on high-risk deep tech. The tenure of the fund should be longer than other funds given the longer gestation period for deep tech startups.
- Pre-commercial funding support through a 2-stage common grant
framework. These two phases of the grant are:
- Minimum grant of INR 20 million for proof of concept; and
- Minimum grant of INR 30 million for tested prototype.
- Pilot testing fund for select startups to conduct field trials for the Government and demonstrate on ground feasibility. The issuance of these funds may be conditional, or milestone based, sanctioned with seed funds.
- Creation of a debt fund in accordance with the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Alternative Investment Funds) Regulations, 2012, which allows for borrowing or leveraging to meet the exclusive needs for operational and working capital requirement of deep tech startups, supported by the Credit Guarantee Scheme for Startups.
- Fiscal incentives and tax rebates to attract General Partners (GP) and LPs from the investor community for allocation of certain funds from their corpus towards deep tech startups.
- "Technology Impact Bond" model attracting investment during development phase and addressing the hurdles of long gestation period and financial investment.
To view the full article, click here.
Footnotes
1. Launched on January 16, 2016 by the Ministry of Commerce and Industry, https://www.startupindia.gov.in/content/sih/en/about-startup-india-initiative.html (accessed on March 21, 2024, at 21:45 hours, India time).
2. Chaired by the Principal Scientific Adviser to the Government of India, the National Consortium represents a broad spectrum of stakeholders including high-level representatives from the Department for Promotion of Industry and Internal Trade (DPIIT), Atal Innovation Mission (AIM), NITI Aayog, Ministry of Electronics and Information Technology (MeitY), Department of Biotechnology (DBT), Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO), National Security Council Secretariat (NSCS), Defence Research and Development Organisation (DRDO), National Association of Software and Service Companies (NASSCOM), Confederation of Indian Industry (CII), and Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce & Industry (FICCI).
3. See: https://pib.gov.in/PressReleaseIframePage.aspx?PRID=1944369 (accessed on March 21, 2024, at 21:31 hours, India time).
4. Interim Union Budget Speech for FY 2024-25, https://www.indiabudget.gov.in/doc/budget_speech.pdf (accessed on March 21, 2024, at 20:15 hours, India time).
5. See: https://www.psa.gov.in/deep-tech-policy (accessed on March 21, 2024, at 21:58 hours, India time).
6. Annexure I(b), draft National Deep Tech Startup Policy.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.