Plutus Payroll: The famous tax evasion case

JB Solicitors


Our team would be known as inspiring leaders within the community, displaying strong leadership on important issues in society even if it comes at a short-term cost. In delivering value by being both innovative and convenient, using technology and shifting the culture of work-life in the profession, we will attract the best and most diverse team of people. By creating opportunity and revolutionising our segment of the Profession through innovation and convenience for clients, we will assert a strong belief that having work experience at JB Solicitors is a door-opening in the legal profession. The knowledge and experience gained in working at our firm will be equivalent to, if not better than, obtaining an internship at a large top tier law firm.
The Plutus Payroll fraud case became a key focus for the Serious Financial Crime Taskforce in 2017.
Australia Criminal Law
To print this article, all you need is to be registered or login on

The Plutus Payroll case, a major tax evasion operation, exposed in 2017 completely upended Australia's tax system. Operation Elbrus, also known as the Plutus Payroll fraud, was a joint AFP and Australian Taxation Office (ATO) investigation. This case became a key focus for the Serious Financial Crime Taskforce in 2017.

Taxes pay for infrastructure, social programs, healthcare, education, and other necessities, even though they frequently annoy taxpayers. However, under the surface lies a perennial threat: tax evasion. This willful underpayment of taxes or outright tax evasion undermines the fundamental system that keeps us alive.

It's a covert action, frequently veiled in mystery, motivated by the desire to take advantage of the system for one's benefit. Tax evasion involves illegally reducing your tax bill. Here are some common methods:

  1. Hiding income: This is the most common tactic. People might underreport their wages, business income, interest income, or income from side hustles. They might do this by using cash for transactions or creating fake businesses to funnel money through.
  2. Overstating deductions: People might claim deductions for expenses they didn't incur, inflate the value of legitimate deductions, or claim deductions they don't qualify for.
  3. Filing fake tax returns: This involves creating fictitious income or deductions or submitting multiple tax returns under different identities.
  4. Using offshore accounts: Some people try to hide their assets and income by placing them in bank accounts in countries with strict secrecy laws.

The Plutus Payroll case is a stark reminder of the lengths to which some will go to evade their tax obligations. This deceptive and elaborate scheme, masterminded by individuals within the payroll industry, defrauded the government of approximately $165 million. Read on to learn more.

What Transpired During the Plutus Payroll Case?

Arrogance can be a dangerous gamble, as a group of tax evaders discovered this the hard way. Lawyer Dev Menon, boasting about his role in concealing the elaborate Plutus Payroll scam, unwittingly issued a challenge to Australia's top forensic accountants. He believed the scheme's complexity was an impenetrable maze, a "blessing in disguise."

Little did he know, the Australian Federal Police (AFP) were listening, eager to prove him wrong. The AFP rose to the occasion, spearheaded by Assistant Commissioner Kirsty Schofield. Over 30 terabytes of digital evidence were gathered, forming a comprehensive case presented to the NSW Supreme Court.

The Plutus Payroll trial itself became a house of cards for the five co-conspirators – Adam and Lauren Cranston, Jason Onley, Menon, and Patrick Willmott. Mr. Onley was also a key facilitator in the creation and operation of the scheme. He also helped second tier companies and also helped to conceal the scheme from authorities. Their attempts to deflect blame and feign ignorance crumbled under the weight of the evidence.

Adam Cranston, the scheme's mastermind, faced the harshest consequences. Justice Anthony Payne dismissed his claims of innocence as "preposterous," highlighting the significant financial gains Cranston reaped from the fraud. Efforts to pin blame on deceased associate Peter Larcombe proved futile.

The Investigation Stage

The investigation of the Plutus Payroll case revealed the scheme's underbelly. Devised in Sydney strip clubs, it involved a web of shell companies and dummy directors designed to siphon money from payroll taxes owed to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO). The seemingly legitimate facade masked a criminal operation.

Justice Payne delivered a powerful message during sentencing. He emphasised the stolen funds' impact on the Commonwealth and condemned the notion of tax evasion as a victimless crime. He warned against the false belief that such acts are merely "immoral but not illegal," reminding everyone that severe punishment awaits those who engage in such corruption.

The Plutus Payroll case concluded a seven-year investigation, according to Assistant Commissioner Schofield. The ATO froze Plutus Payroll's accounts and, in May, the AFP made arrests. All key players are believed to be facing justice, and efforts continue to recover the stolen funds.

The downfall of the Plutus scheme serves as a stark reminder that underestimating law enforcement's tenacity can lead to a swift and decisive collapse.

Read: Tax Fraud and Australian Law | JB Solicitors

The Hidden Cost: How Tax Evasion Weakens Australia

We all rely on essential services like healthcare, education, and infrastructure. These services are funded largely by taxes we pay. But what happens when some choose to avoid paying their fair share? This is where the shadow economy comes in.

The shadow economy refers to hidden activities that operate outside the tax and regulatory systems. Businesses and individuals participating in this economy may underreport income, deal in cash to avoid a paper trail or operate entirely off the books.

While most Australians pay their taxes honestly, those who don't directly weaken the foundation of our society. Less tax revenue translates to less funding for crucial services. This means potentially longer wait times for surgeries, fewer school resources, and delayed roads and public transportation upgrades.

Let's use an example. A devastating bushfire rips through a community. Emergency services need resources to respond, but funds are limited due to tax evasion. This is the real-world impact of the shadow economy.

The Role of Accountants

The Plutus Payroll case highlighted the dangers of relying on untrustworthy third-party vendors. Accountants can help businesses by carefully vetting potential vendors and maintaining open communication with existing ones. They can also recommend tools to control transactions and ensure proper payment verification.

Accountants can further protect legitimate clients from internal financial crimes by identifying areas at risk and implementing strong controls. Technology like data analytics can assist in detecting suspicious activity. Finally, fostering a culture of transparency empowers employees to report concerns and strengthens the overall financial health of the business.

Reach out to Us About Tax Fraud and Evasion Matters

Even the biggest tax fraud cannot evade law enforcement forever. Missing receipts, unusually high cash transactions, or a general sense of secrecy surrounding finances could raise red flags. Indeed catching perpetrators might seem like a job for law enforcement. However, lawyers particularly those specialising in tax law, play a critical behind-the-scenes role in uncovering and resolving these complex cases.

JB Solicitors can be your guide in such situations. They can help you analyse the evidence you have and determine if it's strong enough to suggest tax evasion. They can advise on gathering additional information legally and ethically with government agencies.

The process of reporting suspected tax evasion can be confusing. A lawyer can ensure you follow the appropriate channels, whether anonymously to the Australian Taxation Office (ATO) or directly with evidence. This protects you from potential legal repercussions if your suspicions turn out to be unfounded.

The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.

See More Popular Content From

Mondaq uses cookies on this website. By using our website you agree to our use of cookies as set out in our Privacy Policy.

Learn More