The Supreme Court on May 20 ruled in PPL Corp. v.
Commissioner that the one-time "windfall tax"
imposed by the United Kingdom in 1997 had a predominant character
of a "classic excess profits tax" and thus could be used
in computing the foreign tax credit under Section 901.
Between 1984 and 1996, the UK parliament began privatizing
government-owned companies and sold shares in them in an initial
offering. PPL Corporation became a 25% owner of one of those
companies, South Western Electricity plc. In 1997, a new political
party came to power and imposed a 23% windfall tax on the
privatized companies, which by then had become wildly profitable.
The tax was based on a formulary approach designed to capture
excess profits resulting from the privatization.
South Western Electricity's windfall tax burden was
£90.4 million. In its 1997 federal income tax return, PPL
claimed a credit under Section 901 for its portion of the tax. The
IRS rejected the claim.
The Tax Court held that the windfall tax was creditable and had
the predominant character of a U.S. income tax in that it passed
the realization, gross receipts and net income requirements of reg.
The IRS appealed to the Third Circuit Court of Appeals and won,
with the court holding that the windfall tax did not pass the gross
receipts requirement. Around the same time, however, the Fifth
Circuit heard an appeal in a companion case and sided with the
taxpayer, setting up a Supreme Court challenge.
Supreme Court's reasoning
The Supreme Court, in a unanimous opinion authored by Justice
Clarence Thomas, analyzed the nature of the tax under reg. section
1.901-2 and held that the windfall tax met the requirements for
creditability, because the tax essentially functioned as an excess
profits tax. Under Section 901(b)(1), taxes paid to a foreign
country by a domestic corporation on income, war profits and excess
profits is creditable.
The Court ruled that was substantively a 51.71% tax on profits
above a certain threshold and that the predominant nature of the
tax was based on the net income.
The Court reiterated that the correct analysis in determining
creditability under Section 901 is to evaluate the economic effect
of the tax, not its characterization by the foreign government.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.
To print this article, all you need is to be registered on Mondaq.com.
Click to Login as an existing user or Register so you can print this article.
Employers with medical reimbursement plans such as health reimbursement arrangements need to review them as soon as possible, to make sure they don’t accumulate heavy tax penalties from noncompliance with Affordable Care Act rules.
In 2014, the U.S. Tax Court issued two opinions with significant implications in the captive insurance world. On January 14, 2014, the court issued a reviewed decision in Rent-A-Center, Inc. v. Commissioner.