Trump's upcoming inauguration for our neighbor down south is looming as many of us are still coming to terms with the election results. To say that the election was a controversial and polarizing one is a gross understatement. Canada tuned in, as social media, newspapers, radio stations and everything in between exploded with every tweet, every colourful comment made at the debates, and pieces dug up from the candidates' past.
Everyone woke up on November 9, 2016 to the news of Trump's stunning victory. However, for some Canadians that morning, Trump hit much closer to home. On the morning of November 9, 2016, Judge Bernd Zabel walked into the courtroom wearing a "Make America Great Again" cap before placing it on the bench in front of him. In the same courtroom on that day, he voiced his support for Donald Trump.
This sparked outrage as the future president-elect has appeared to condone sexual assault on women and threaten various ethnic and sexual minorities, among others. However, more disturbing and problematic is the fact that judges, otherwise seen as the beacons of justice in Canada, are required to be impartial and neutral. One of the underlying values of the Canadian justice system, judicial independence, requires judges to make decisions pursuant to the rule of law absent any political interference. The Canadian Judicial Council provides that "Judges should strive to conduct themselves in a way that will sustain and contribute to public respect and confidence in their integrity, impartiality and good judgment."
The legal community reacted instantly with many calling for Justice Zabel to be disciplined. Justice Zabel quickly apologized the next week – "I wish to apologize for my misguided attempt to mark a moment in history by humour in the courtroom following the surprising result in the United States election". However, just as an apology cannot absolve someone of wrongdoing or undo a contract, it cannot take back words that were said. Action was taken quickly, as Justice Zabel has now been suspended, and can no longer hear cases in court as of December 21, 2016. While Justice Zabel's future remains uncertain, we know that Canadian courts strive to be better than great.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.