As a general rule, silence will not lead to any legal liability.
Indeed, the image of lawyers telling their clients "not to say
a word" is part of almost every courtroom drama. In the
context of contractual negotiations, however, it is important to
verify that material statements made to the other side are accurate
A Duty to Disclose
Generally in a contractual relationship between sophisticated
parties there is no duty to disclose anything to the other side.
Mere silence does not constitute misrepresentation. However, once a
representation is made, as typically happens in the context of
negotiations, it must be accurate. The Alberta Court of Queen's
Bench in Opron Construction Co. v. Alberta has interpreted
this act of making a representation as giving rise to a duty of
disclosure. This duty is an ongoing obligation that extends beyond
the negotiating table; any accidental misstatements must be
clarified once they are discovered so that the other party has
accurate information on which to rely. Similarly, any statements
which, although true when made, have been rendered inaccurate due
to changing circumstances, must be corrected. In the context of
complex negotiations that may take months and result in significant
volumes of documents, parties should take careful note of what has
been said on key issues so that liability is not accidentally
The Whole Truth
Merely ensuring the accuracy of statements is not enough,
however. Any statement made must also be comprehensive. The Supreme
Court in National Bank of Canada v. Soucisse held that
once a party to a contract has disclosed some information, it has a
duty to disclose all of that information, completely, because
"partial information is misleading information."
Similarly, where a direct question is asked in the process of
negotiations, it must be answered truthfully, honestly, and fully.
In other words, it must be both accurate and comprehensive.
When Misrepresentation is Actionable
Not every statement made in the course of negotiations attracts
liability as a misrepresentation. This is sensible given the time
and cost that would be needed to vet every representation. Rather,
misrepresentations will only attract liability if they are (1)
material, and (2) induced the other side, relying on the
misrepresentation, to enter into the deal.
According to the Alberta Court of Appeal in L.K. Oil &
Gas v. Canalands Energy Corp, in order to be material, a
"statement must be of such a nature that it would be likely to
induce a person to enter into a contract." Therefore, trivial
or insignificant details should not give rise to concern. Any
statements concerning significant issues, however, must be vetted
for accuracy to prevent the possibility of liability.
Proper diligence concerning the statements made during
negotiations should be a focus of any company. Indeed, employing
proper safeguards to prevent actionable misrepresentations is
relatively straightforward. Firstly, employees and representatives
involved in negotiations should be kept up to date on information
pertinent to central issues surrounding the contract so that
representations or responses to questions by the other party can be
answered fully the first time. Secondly, representations made
concerning material issues, should be recorded and reviewed so that
errors may be corrected and accurate statements may be kept up to
date with changing circumstances.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general
guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought
about your specific circumstances.
To print this article, all you need is to be registered on Mondaq.com.
Click to Login as an existing user or Register so you can print this article.
Please join us for a discussion of the legal and business aspects involved in the planning, construction and completion of a development project in downtown Toronto. The panel will use an office tower as a case study, but the analysis will be applicable to commercial and industrial developments, including hotels and shopping centres.
Construction projects come with a host of challenges – from securing project financing to procurement issues and the avoidance and resolution of disputes. Timely resolution of these issues, and the identification and anticipation of potential future hiccups before they occur, can save valuable time and resources.
Join leading experts from Blakes for an interactive panel discussion on how to navigate the increasingly complex construction environment in Canada. The seminar will focus on practical ways to manage emerging risks in your day-to-day operations.
Project financing: how to get lenders to say yes (and why they say no)
Procurement: avoiding common issues
Dispute avoidance and resolution, during and after the project
Strong negotiation skills are key to career advancement and success. Being able to help others overcome differences to reach mutually beneficial agreements is an essential leadership skill. Collaborative negotiation, the most sophisticated and effective negotiation approach, is a natural core competency of many women, although it is often difficult to master.
During the program, preparation for complex negotiations using both a competitive and collaborative mindset will be discussed. Strategies for more easily uncovering and using mutual interests for maximum outcome will be presented. Ultimately, you will optimize and build upon your negotiation strengths for greater success at work.
In Ontario Securities Commission v. Tiffin, the Ontario Court of Justice clarified the limits of the definition of "securities" under s.1(1) of the Securities Act, as it relates to promissory notes. The defendant in the case was charged with trading in securities without being registered and while prohibited, and without filing a prospectus.
The OSC has issued a press release advising stakeholders that Ontario securities law may apply to any use of distributed ledger technologies, such as blockchain, as part of financial products or service offerings.
The use of electronic signatures is becoming increasingly commonplace in commercial transactions, as individuals and businesses capitalize on the administrative efficiency afforded by today’s digital world.
Register for Access and our Free Biweekly Alert for
This service is completely free. Access 250,000 archived articles from 100+ countries and get a personalised email twice a week covering developments (and yes, our lawyers like to think you’ve read our Disclaimer).