In our previous issue of Insurable Interest we reported on a recent decision of the Victoria Supreme Court arising from the Black Saturday bushfires of 2009. Justice Forrest found that the lead plaintiff in the Horsham bushfire class action was entitled to recover damages for farm fixtures (fences, sheds and stockyards) destroyed by fire where he has used his own labour and the labour of volunteers to reinstate the property. As we reported, Powercor appealed Justice Forrest's decision on this point.
On appeal, Powercor again argued that the plaintiff should not be entitled to damages for his own labour unless he could establish that he suffered a loss to his income producing activities while he was carrying out the repairs. Powercor also argued that the plaintiff had an obligation to mitigate his losses by undertaking the repairs himself where he had the capacity to do so.
These arguments were comprehensively rejected by the Victorian Court of Appeal in a unanimous decision. The key finding is that the plaintiff was entitled to compensation for the damage directly to fixtures at the time of the fire. The loss crystallised at that time and is to be measured by the reasonable commercial cost of the labour. His claim was not for consequential loss. It follows that the question of mitigation is irrelevant. The Court contrasted the plaintiff's claim with a claim for the cost of agisting cattle while fences are repaired which is a claim for consequential loss and which may involve questions of mitigation.
It was also held that the key question in relation to voluntary labour is whether the volunteer undertook the work for the plaintiff's benefit or in order to reduce Powercor's liability. In this case, it was agreed by both parties that the volunteer labour was for the benefit of the plaintiff. Accordingly, the Court ruled that the voluntary labour should not be taken into account so as to reduce Powercor's liability for the property damage.
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.
