In the media
Firm's exclusion from Bendigo hospital tender
unlawful, court rules
The Federal Court has ruled the Victorian Government's
exclusion of a major construction company from building the Bendigo
Hospital was unlawful. The Construction, Forestry, Mining and
Energy Union (CFMEU) took action against the State Government over
its handling of tenders for the Bendigo project (18 May 2013).
More...
Green Star rating tool for public buildings helps keep budgets in the black
The Green Star – Public Building rating tool released after a two-year pilot period and extensive industry consultation opens the door to Green Star certification for Australia's public buildings, according to the GBCA's Chief Executive (14 May 2013). More...
New safety rules legislation to protect offshore
workers
In passing the Offshore Petroleum and Greenhouse Gas Storage
Amendment (Compliance Measures No.2) Bill 2013, the Senate has
strengthened Australia's offshore petroleum regulatory regime
to safeguard against the destruction caused by the uncontrolled
release of hydrocarbons that was seen with the Montara Wellhead
Platform in August 2009 (15 May 2013).
More...
Building Australia's Future: 2013-2014
budget
The 2013–14 Budget not only continues the rollout of the
Federal Labour Government's record capital works program, it
also begins identifying future funding priorities, with the
nation's regional highways and urban public transport
infrastructure set to be the big winners (14 May 2013).
More...
Roads to Receive Additional $3 Billion of Funding in
budget
The federal government has signalled its commitment to road
infrastructure with the announcement that three key road projects
in Brisbane, Melbourne and Sydney will benefit from more than $3
billion of additional funding in the budget (14 May 2013).
More...
House Price Growth slump in early 2013
House price growth in Australia's capital cities stagnated in
the first quarter of 2013, according to the Housing Industry
Association (HIA), with the price of established homes in
Australia's capital cities edged up by just 0.1 per cent in the
first quarter of this year (07 May 2013).
More...
Australian Construction Index Hits Seven Month
Low
In the latest sign of the fragility of the recovery in new
building work, a leading indicator of construction industry
conditions in Australia has dropped back to seven month lows. In
April, the Performance of Construction Index contracted by 3.6
points to go from 38.6 to 35.2, according to the Performance of
Construction Index report (07 May 2013).
More...
Council to spend $1.9 billion on City of Sydney's
infrastructure
City of Sydney Lord Mayor Clover Moore has committed to an
overhaul of the inner city's streets and infrastructure by
announcing that the council will embark on its largest ever capital
spending program work worth $1.9 billion over the next decade (14
May 2013).
More...
Second Sydney Airport an Environmental and Engineering
Challenge
In releasing the technical study into Wilton's suitability as
a site, Transport and Infrastructure Minister Anthony Albanese
concluded that it was possible but it would involve environmental
and engineering challenges (13 May2013).
More...
Funding for Brisbane's Cross River Rail Secured in
Budget
The Federal Infrastructure and Transport Minister Anthony Albanese
outlines the Gillard Government's commitment to making
Brisbane's vital Cross River Rail project a reality, with this
week's Budget delivered initial funding of $715 million for
this transformational project (17 May 2013).
More...
New Bruce Highway Overtaking Lanes South of Isis
River
Work has commenced on widening and strengthening the foundations
of the southern approaches to the Isis River Bridge, adding to the
extensive capital works program already underway along the entire
length of the Bruce Highway (08 May 2013).
More...
Melbourne construction standards get
greener
The City of Melbourne increases efforts to become more
environmentally sustainable by pledging an overhaul of building
standards for energy, water and waste efficiency for new
construction projects. The inner metropolitan council has put
forward new building standards in its Planning Scheme Amendment
C187 in the Melbourne Planning Scheme (17 May 2013).
More...
$47 million to boost local infrastructure
planning
The Victorian Coalition Government today committed $47 million to
boost transport and planning infrastructure at the East Werribee
Employment Precinct and Frankston station surrounds (07 May 2013).
More...
Victoria invests $31.7 million to strengthen earth
resources sector
The Victorian Coalition Government announced it will spend $31.7
million over four years on programs to build a strong, safe and
sustainable mining industry, directed to reinvigorating the
State's mining industry by driving a new wave of exploration
and reducing barriers to investment (07 May 2013).
More...
Increased infrastructure spend vital to Victoria's
economic development
Engineers Australia welcomes the Victorian State Budget's plan
to increase spend on critical public transport infrastructure and
other Victorian infrastructure projects, with more than $520
million committed to infrastructure projects throughout the 2013-14
Victorian State Budget (08 May 2013).
More...
Published – articles, papers, reports
House Price Indexes for: Eight Capital Cities, March
2013
Author: Australian Bureau of Statistics
The capital city indexes rose in Perth (+1.2%), Melbourne (+0.2%),
Darwin (+1.9%) and Canberra (+0.2%) and fell in Brisbane (-0.3%),
Adelaide (-0.1%) and Hobart (-0.3%). Sydney showed no movement for
the quarter. Annually, house prices rose in Darwin (+8.0%), Perth
(+6.1%), Sydney (+3.6%), Canberra (+1.5%), Brisbane (+1.4%),
Melbourne (+1.1%) and Adelaide (+0.9%) and fell in Hobart (-1.9%)
(07 May 2013).
More...
Construction Industry in NSW: Background to the
Insolvency Inquiry
Author: NSW Parliamentary Library Research Service. This e-brief
sets out to provide a general survey of the industry, the key areas
of activity and the main participants. It also looks at the
regulation of the industry and at the more important
recommendations of the Collins inquiry (08 May 2013).
More...
National Partnership Agreement on Energy Efficiency
Annual Report to COAG, 2011-12
Author: Council of Australian Governments
The annual consolidated report provided to COAG on overall
progress on implementation. COAG Senior Officials, on behalf of
COAG, have noted the report for 2011-12 (08 May 2013). More...
Energy in Australia 2013
Author: Bureau of Resources and Energy Economics (BREE)
The publication shows that the energy industry is a significant
contributor to the Australian economy, and accounts for around 6
per cent of total industry value added in 2010–11, or around
$79 billion. The report is also accompanied by a fact card of key
energy facts for Australia (08 May 2013). More...
Cases
Construction, Forestry, Mining and Energy Union v State
of Victoria [2013] FCA 445
INDUSTRIAL LAW – s 340(1) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)
– whether respondent took adverse action against employees of
independent contractor because those employees had a workplace
right – whether the employer of the employee's was an
"independent contractor" with whom the respondent was
"proposing to enter into a contract for services" within
the meaning of Item 4 of s 342(1) – meaning of
"independent contractor", "proposing to enter"
and "contract for services" – whether respondent
took adverse action by threatening to refuse to engage independent
contractor or make use of its services – meaning of
"refuse to engage" – meaning of "threatening
to take action" in s 342(2)(a) – whether threat capable
of being made in the context of an agreed process – whether
prohibition imposed by s 340 may be avoided by contract, waiver or
estoppel – whether adverse action taken because the employees
were entitled to the benefit of an industrial instrument –
meaning of "entitled to the benefit" of a workplace
instrument – consideration of s 361 and onus of proof.
CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – Melbourne Corporation limitation
– whether ss 340-342 of Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) exceed the
Constitutional legislative capacity of the Commonwealth by imposing
limitations upon the capacity of a State to select a contractor to
provide major infrastructure.
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – s 21 of the Federal Court of
Australia Act 1976 (Cth) – whether declaration may be made in
the absence of a justiciable controversy. More...
Bluechip Development Corporation (Gladstone) Pty Ltd v
Sunstruct Pty Ltd & Ors [2013] FCCA 141
CONSUMER LAW – Misleading or deceptive conduct –
consumer protection – trade or commerce – construction
management agreement – representations as to performance of
various terms alleged to induce entry into agreement –
finance agreement constituted by Tripartite Deed –
representation as to performance of construction management
agreement by entry into Tripartite Deed – claimant pursuant
to Building and Construction Industry Payment Act (QLD) –
alleged representation said to follow upon claim pursuant to that
Act – no contravention established.
ACCESSORIAL LIABILITY OF DIRECTORS– Prima facie duty –
no breach established DAMAGES – s.82 and s.87 – damages
pursuant to s.82 exceed courts monetary jurisdiction –
circumstances relevant to award of damages pursuant to s.87 –
global damages sought – tactical decision to claim – no
basis for favourable discretion.
CONTRACT – Breach of contract – terms of construction
management agreement to determine works budget, cause works to be
carried out, monitor costs, have available staff to fulfill terms,
perform service to requisite standard – finding of no breach.
TORT – Duty of care – breach of duty of care –
evidence required to establish claim – failure to lead
evidence –no breach of duty established.
FIDUCIARY DUTY – Question of vulnerability –
arrangement commercial and guaranteed by contract – no
conflict of duty and interest. BUILDING LICENSE – Duty
pursuant to Queensland Building Services Authority Act to have
builder's registration – nominee suffered illness through
course of project – subsequent resignation of nominee as
director of building company – contractual performance of
oversight by nominee for corporate contractor. GLOBAL DAMAGES
– Claimed in respect of tort, contract and fiduciary claim
– strict requirement for proof. BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION
INDUSTRY ACT – Common law relief following adjudication
– claim for supervision fees – favourable adjudication
– basis for disposal at common law – award assessed.
Building and Construction Industry Payments Act 2004 (Qld),
Queensland Building Services Authority Act 1991 (Qld), s.42 (1),
Trade Practices Act 1974 (Cth), ss.52, 87.
More...
Go Electrical Pty Limited v Class Electrical Services
Pty Limited [2013] NSWSC 517
Plaintiff forthwith repays to the defendant the sum of $39,166.19
which includes interest to the date of judgment. PRACTICE AND
PROCEDURE - where monies recovered by a party under a judgment
based on an adjudication determination - where adjudication
determination is quashed and judgment set aside - right of the
party from whom the monies were recovered to return of the monies -
whether the Court has a discretion to not order repayment. Building
and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 (NSW);
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth); Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005;
Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW). More...
Maxstra NSW Pty Ltd v Blacklabel Services Pty Ltd [2013]
NSWSC 406
BUILDING AND ENGINEERING CONTRACTS - Building and Construction
Industry Security of Payment Act 1999 - challenge to adjudication
determination - claim for work either as variation or on quantum
meruit - allegation that amount claimed is within the contract
price - not a matter raised in payment schedule and inconsistent
with contractual documents - allegation of denial of procedural
fairness and error of law - no error of law involved in
determination - alleged denial of procedural fairness had no
practical impact - no jurisdictional error - Building and
Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999. More...
St Hilliers Construction Pty Ltd v Fitzpatrick
Investments Pty Ltd [2013] NSWCA 104
Orders that the appeal be allowed. BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION -
where contract required contractor to provide bank guarantees as
security for performance - where contractor entitled to reduction
of security if conditions fulfilled - whether conditions satisfied.
More...
Silver Star Construction Pty Limited t/as Genesis
Construction Australia v Denham Constructions Pty Limited [2011]
NSWDC 254
Defendant (Denham Constructions Pty Limited) to pay the
plaintiff's (Silver Star Constructions Pty Limited) costs.
Security of payment; stay of enforcement; competing interests - The
Building and Construction Industry Security of Payment Act 1999
(NSW) (SOPA); Civil Procedure Act 2005. More...
McNab NQ Pty Ltd v Walkrete Pty Ltd & Ors [2013] QSC
128
ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – JUDICIAL REVIEW – GROUNDS OF
REVIEW – JURISDICTIONAL MATTERS –Employees of the
subcontractor first respondent created a substantial safety risk in
breach of instructions given by the applicant – The
sub-contract allowed termination by the applicant for the first
respondent's default "in the performance or observance of
any serious condition" – The applicant terminated its
sub-contract with the first respondent, alleging the first
respondent's safety breach contravened a "serious
condition" – A subsequent payment claim by the first
respondent was upheld by an adjudicator under the Building and
Construction Industry Payments Act 2004 – Whether the
adjudicator had jurisdiction to determine the adjudication
application – Whether the sub-contract had been validly
terminated for breach of a "serious condition". More...
Lucas Drilling Pty Limited v Armour Energy Limited
[2013] QCA 111
APPEAL AND NEW TRIAL – PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE –
QUEENSLAND – POWERS OF THE COURT – ORDERS SET ASIDE OR
VARIED – where there was a contract under which the
respondent undertook to provide drilling services to the appellant
– where the appellant was granted an interlocutory injunction
to restrain the respondent from calling on a bank guarantee which
the appellant had procured in favour of the respondent –
where the learned primary judge had established that there was a
serious question to be tried and that the balance of convenience
favoured the granting of injunctive relief, conditional upon the
appellant (in this proceeding) paying the amount of the guarantee
into court – where the appellant contended that the learned
primary judge erred in the exercise of the discretion to grant
interlocutory relief – whether the primary's judge's
discretion miscarried. CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND
RELATED CONTRACTS – THE CONTRACT – CONSTRUCTION OF
PARTICULAR CONTRACTS AND IMPLIED CONDITIONS – OTHER MATTERS
– where there was a contract under which the respondent
undertook to provide drilling services to the appellant –
where the appellant was granted an interlocutory injunction to
restrain the respondent from calling on a bank guarantee which the
appellant had procured in favour of the respondent – where
the appellant contended that the learned primary judge erred in the
exercise of the discretion to grant interlocutory relief –
where there was a dispute about the proper construction of the
contractual clause concerning the performance bond – where
the appellant contended that, by virtue of its accrued rights, it
was not obliged to return the performance bond, notwithstanding
termination of the contract by the respondent – where the
respondent contended that the appellant had no accrued rights and
was obliged to return the performance bond – whether the
proper construction of the contract obliged the appellant to return
the performance bond – whether serious case to be tried. More...
G&N Building Contractors Pty Ltd v Queensland
Building Services Authority [2013] QCAT 125
Summary Disposal – where the decision under review is not a
reviewable decision – where Tribunal has no power to extend
time. Smith v Queensland Building Services Authority [2010] QCAT
448; Customizer Kitchens Qld v Queensland Building Services
Authority [2011] QCAT 13; Cornpig Pty Ltd v Queensland Building
Services Authority [2011] QCAT 255. More...
McCarthy t/as PJ McCarthy Commercial and Residential
Builders v The State of Queensland (No 2) [2013] QDC
104
COSTS ORDER - APPLICATION – summary judgment –
application dismissed - statutory debt - Building and Construction
Industry Payments Act 2004 (QLD) – section 19 - Uniform Civil
Procedure Rules 1999 (QLD) – rule 292 – whether payment
claim valid – progress payments – where no reference
date specified under contract – where contract provided time
for making payments was 'monthly' – where alleged
multiple payment claims made in relation to earlier reference dates
- whether a real prospect of defending a claim - whether no need
for a trial – where plaintiff ought to be put to strict proof
of his claim. More...
Jensen v Queensland Building Services Authority [2013]
QCAT 121
GENERAL ADMINISTRATIVE REVIEW – PERMITTED INDIVIDUAL –
relevant event – circumstances – insolvency –
harassment and proposal to cancel licence – insulation scheme
– non-payment by debtors – reasonable steps –
previous proposal to cancel licence. Benz v Queensland Building
Services Authority [2010] QCAT 625, applied FAI Insurances Ltd v
Winneke (1981) 151 CLR 342, cited Papallo v Queensland Building
Services Authority [2012] QCAT 59, applied Vadasz v Queensland
Building Services Authority [2013] QCAT 84, applied Younan v
Queensland Building Services Authority [2010] QDC 158, applied
Younan v Queensland Building Services Authority [2011] QCA 1,
applied. More...
Mt Cotton Constructions Pty Ltd v Brisbane City Council
[2013] QCAT 119
JURISDICTION – where Council provided fill for hockey field
– where builder claims fill unsuitable – where builder
claims damages for removal of fill and reinstatement –
whether tribunal has jurisdiction – whether a building
dispute – whether commercial building dispute – whether
reviewable commercial work – whether tribunal work. Fraser
Property Developments Pty Ltd v Sommerfeld (No. 1) [2005] Qd R 394
Saliba v Bethscheider [1998] QBT 87. More...
Maxstra Constructions Pty Ltd v Gilbert & Ors [2013]
VSC 243
BUILDING CONTRACTS - Building and Construction Industry Security
of Payment Act 2002 (Vic) – Adjudication conducted under Part
3 Division 2 of the Act - Apparent conflict between s 10B(2)(c)
with s 11(1)(b)(iv) of the Act - Conflict resolved by application
of statutory construction principles -Adjudicator erred in
statutory construction - Jurisdictional error - Certiorari granted
- Determination of adjudicator quashed and matter remitted for
determination in accordance with the law. STATUTES INTERPRETATION -
Apparent conflict between provisions of an Act - Conflict resolved
by application of statutory construction principles - Project Blue
Sky v Australian Broadcasting Authority [1998] HCA 28 at [69]- [71]
considered and applied. More...
The content of this article is intended to provide a general guide to the subject matter. Specialist advice should be sought about your specific circumstances.